Stillen Gen 3 Ultra Long VS K&N Typhoon Dual CAI (Winter?)
#1
Stillen Gen 3 Ultra Long VS K&N Typhoon Dual CAI (Winter?)
Hello everyone,
Newbie here to the Club. Great information everywhere. I have spent the last couple days reading the forums but can't find an answer to a dilemma I have. Please direct me to a post if this has been discussed earlier.
I just purchased a 2008 G35x Sport Sedan with 154XXX miles on it from a dealer. The car will be going in the shop for a checkup since it has that many miles and was sold as is. Once the necessary repairs are made, I would like to add an intake to the engine. A G35x I test drove had the K&N dual intake installed and I fell in love with the growling of the engine and the stock sound can't compete with the sound of the intake.
My question is, since I live in the upper Midwest and our winters are long, how would a CAI perform like the Stillen? Will I have problems with the snow and puddles since it will be installed behind the grill, essentially? Should I stick with the K&N intake even though the air it will be sucking-in may be hotter?
Does the Stillen sound better than the K&N intake (https://www.knfilters.com/cold-air-i.../g35/3.5l/2008). The car will be a daily city driver, so mostly on the lower RPM spectrum. Also, do you recommend that I tune the car after installing the intake to ensure it is not running lean or anything? I plan on installing a plenum spacer as well and no more mods will be made. I just want a little sound.
Thank you for your help!!
Newbie here to the Club. Great information everywhere. I have spent the last couple days reading the forums but can't find an answer to a dilemma I have. Please direct me to a post if this has been discussed earlier.
I just purchased a 2008 G35x Sport Sedan with 154XXX miles on it from a dealer. The car will be going in the shop for a checkup since it has that many miles and was sold as is. Once the necessary repairs are made, I would like to add an intake to the engine. A G35x I test drove had the K&N dual intake installed and I fell in love with the growling of the engine and the stock sound can't compete with the sound of the intake.
My question is, since I live in the upper Midwest and our winters are long, how would a CAI perform like the Stillen? Will I have problems with the snow and puddles since it will be installed behind the grill, essentially? Should I stick with the K&N intake even though the air it will be sucking-in may be hotter?
Does the Stillen sound better than the K&N intake (https://www.knfilters.com/cold-air-i.../g35/3.5l/2008). The car will be a daily city driver, so mostly on the lower RPM spectrum. Also, do you recommend that I tune the car after installing the intake to ensure it is not running lean or anything? I plan on installing a plenum spacer as well and no more mods will be made. I just want a little sound.
Thank you for your help!!
Last edited by MING35x; 03-19-2019 at 12:14 PM.
#2
#4
I drove ttrank's car solo
iTrader: (50)
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: By the sea, Tx
Posts: 18,301
Received 1,486 Likes
on
1,221 Posts
G35 sedan w/ too much money in mods
If it were me I'd avoid the K&N because as you mentioned it will suck in the hot air in the engine bay. I can't answer whether the Stillen, or any other intake that sits behind the grill, will be OK in the winter but there won't be a dramatic difference in sound between different intakes. They all have open filters which will create very similar amplified sucking noises. A tune won't be necessary but we recommend it anyway. It really changes the way a car runs/drives, even on a stock car.
#5
If it were me I'd avoid the K&N because as you mentioned it will suck in the hot air in the engine bay. I can't answer whether the Stillen, or any other intake that sits behind the grill, will be OK in the winter but there won't be a dramatic difference in sound between different intakes. They all have open filters which will create very similar amplified sucking noises. A tune won't be necessary but we recommend it anyway. It really changes the way a car runs/drives, even on a stock car.
Any idea what such a tune would cost on average?
What do you guys think of this Takeda? . SRI but if I stick a heat shield on it, I am wondering if it will help with the heat. Will two of these fit in the engine bay? I know the SRI and CAI topic has been beaten to death, so no need to go down that route. Or this one looks interesting with the heat shield. Thanks.
https://afepower.com/afe-power-tr-30...m#applications
Last edited by MING35x; 03-20-2019 at 01:10 AM.
#6
Pretty sure neither of those will fit, the one on amazon shows a VQ35DE which has a completely different intake setup, and the one on afepower says for a first gen. Now, I could be wrong, as I only know what my 08 G35x has, but I'm pretty sure your xS has the HR engine with the dual intakes.
#7
Pretty sure neither of those will fit, the one on amazon shows a VQ35DE which has a completely different intake setup, and the one on afepower says for a first gen. Now, I could be wrong, as I only know what my 08 G35x has, but I'm pretty sure your xS has the HR engine with the dual intakes.
Any idea how much a tune would cost?
Trending Topics
#9
Join Date: May 2017
Location: Washington State
Posts: 14,792
Received 2,456 Likes
on
2,150 Posts
Coupe 6MT Premium RAS
Check out Z1 motorsports. Also, you won't have issue sucking slush unless you remove the filter. It literally has to be sitting in a puddle of water before you ever get water past the filter. I've run intakes like that on trucks for YEARS and they've all been driven heavily through puddles and winter weather. You get more moisture from driving in texas during the humid months and it doesn't cause any problems. In order to suck water that thing has to be SUBMERGED in it.
#11
Check out Z1 motorsports. Also, you won't have issue sucking slush unless you remove the filter. It literally has to be sitting in a puddle of water before you ever get water past the filter. I've run intakes like that on trucks for YEARS and they've all been driven heavily through puddles and winter weather. You get more moisture from driving in texas during the humid months and it doesn't cause any problems. In order to suck water that thing has to be SUBMERGED in it.
#12
#13
I drove ttrank's car solo
iTrader: (50)
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: By the sea, Tx
Posts: 18,301
Received 1,486 Likes
on
1,221 Posts
G35 sedan w/ too much money in mods
Be forewarned Weapon R products are crap pretty much across the brand. The foam filters have a tendency to deteriorate over time and I've seen more than one post on other saying that the foam pieces made their way into their motors. Look on this site alone and you'll be hard pressed to find ANYONE who uses their products. Yes it seems R2C is dead which makes me sad. I was a huge supporter of them and their products and ran an R2C intake on our 05. Since the G is now dead Edgarc6789 is the proud new owner of our old one.
And the mechanic is wrong. The heat in the engine bay is brutal even in a colder climate. Maybe not a 0*F but more than half of the year up there you're looking at temps upwards of a 120* and up and a SRI just feeds that brutally hot air into the motor. If it were me I'd send back the WR and get an intake that meets in front of the radiator or one that feeds the filter down to under the motor.
And the mechanic is wrong. The heat in the engine bay is brutal even in a colder climate. Maybe not a 0*F but more than half of the year up there you're looking at temps upwards of a 120* and up and a SRI just feeds that brutally hot air into the motor. If it were me I'd send back the WR and get an intake that meets in front of the radiator or one that feeds the filter down to under the motor.
#14
Be forewarned Weapon R products are crap pretty much across the brand. The foam filters have a tendency to deteriorate over time and I've seen more than one post on other saying that the foam pieces made their way into their motors. Look on this site alone and you'll be hard pressed to find ANYONE who uses their products. Yes it seems R2C is dead which makes me sad. I was a huge supporter of them and their products and ran an R2C intake on our 05. Since the G is now dead Edgarc6789 is the proud new owner of our old one.
And the mechanic is wrong. The heat in the engine bay is brutal even in a colder climate. Maybe not a 0*F but more than half of the year up there you're looking at temps upwards of a 120* and up and a SRI just feeds that brutally hot air into the motor. If it were me I'd send back the WR and get an intake that meets in front of the radiator or one that feeds the filter down to under the motor.
And the mechanic is wrong. The heat in the engine bay is brutal even in a colder climate. Maybe not a 0*F but more than half of the year up there you're looking at temps upwards of a 120* and up and a SRI just feeds that brutally hot air into the motor. If it were me I'd send back the WR and get an intake that meets in front of the radiator or one that feeds the filter down to under the motor.
#15
I drove ttrank's car solo
iTrader: (50)
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: By the sea, Tx
Posts: 18,301
Received 1,486 Likes
on
1,221 Posts
G35 sedan w/ too much money in mods
It's really your call. A better filter us a great idea but I don't know about the rest of the intake. WR catch cans, coolant overflow tanks and PS fluid tanks by them have failed due to poor welds, shoddy materials and premature rust in other car forums I belong to. So do what you feel is right but let us know what direction you go and how it works out for you.