I found these two cars and I am confused about which would one be a better deal. I am leaning toward's the 03' model because I have been driving an automatic and it's boring, plus the low miles are ridiculous. Please give me your opinion so I can better know which one. I have inspected the 03' model already and I'm going to check out the 05' model today. Thanks!

2005 Infiniti G35, 2-door Coupe, $16K, 47,500 miles, automatic

What I like about it:
mp3/cd player, upgraded leather interior I read about, better trim and console.

What i don't like
automatic drive, the price, is it worth $500 less but double the miles for a newer model?

VS

2003 Infiniti G35, 2-door Coupe, $16.5K, 23,500 miles, Manual 6 sports, Sports edition w/o Navi

What I like:
The low miles, The owner was very nice, free car fax, The excellent condition it was in when I went to check it.

What I don't like:
The non mp3/cd player, the ding on the rear bumper, Brembo brake that dont' last very long I read.