Ok, my rims apparently don't have the correct offset because my tires are practically sitting inside the body of the car (if that makes sense), more so in the front than in the back.

Is there anything I can buy, like a wheel spacer or something to get rid of the ugliness?

If my description sucks I can try and explain it again.

 

Sorry to hear about your offset difficulties. There are spacers that you can use that will push the wheels out more, but you undoubtedly will require longer wheel studs. Its a pain in the butt, but can be done.