Anyone notice a slight loss in power with the a/c on.
#16
Guest
Posts: n/a
#17
#18
Originally Posted by Corgidog
In retrospect I probably should not have posted the thread as I was just reacting to a greater cut in power with the a/c on than I had anticipated. My 2 previous cars, a 95 540 and a 00 M roadster, had less of a cut in power with the a/c on than my G and I was a little disappointed in the G with the a/c on. Thanks for the input.
In the A/C Econ. mode the compressor will drop out during hard acceleration.
= less power loss when required.
I use A/C Econ. mode all the time
#19
Originally Posted by AdamsInfiniti
(Not intending to sound like a jerk) Then perhaps you should have posted something along the lines of "Has anyone noticed a greater loss in performance with the A/C on in the G than in other cars?" instead of asking if anyone had noticed a performance loss at all with the A/C on.
No offense, Corgi, but the way you originally wrote your post - it was just begging to be ripped on.
#20
Misanthropic nut-cracker
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: On the water at the "Jersey Shore"...Toms River
Posts: 803
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
No offense C-Dog....it was just too easy to have a little fun at your expense. Lord knows I've suffered the same torching for my condesending retorts and over zealous opinions. No place here on this site for thin skin, but always room for a little self effacing retrospect. And, in addition to answer your amended question.....I've noticed only a very small power loss in the scenario you described. JBX
#21
#22
Originally Posted by Nickk6
I've heard an engine can lose something like %25 of its HP while the A/C is on. Anyone know if this is true?
I've noticed a slight power loss, but not enough that this car needs it off for passing.
I've noticed a slight power loss, but not enough that this car needs it off for passing.
C.
#23
Originally Posted by Corgidog
In retrospect I probably should not have posted the thread as I was just reacting to a greater cut in power with the a/c on than I had anticipated. My 2 previous cars, a 95 540 and a 00 M roadster, had less of a cut in power with the a/c on than my G and I was a little disappointed in the G with the a/c on. Thanks for the input.
That's probably the discussion intended?... Anyway, aside from one comment that “of course there is an effect on mpg” - has anyone determined that econ gets better mpg than AC without econ? I haven’t noticed any better mileage with it on. On the other hand, the AC is def colder with it off. If mpg does not improve in econ mode, what's the point?
Any "constructive" input?
#24
#27
#30
Originally Posted by Gsedanman
There may be some that inefficient I don't know, but ours takes in the 5 to 10 hp range to operate. Very efficient.
C.
C.
Secondly: Gsedanman, I expect your numbers are pretty close, although I'd peg it on the high end of your range when the compressor is engaged. So Corgi, you bet you'll feel a little tug when the compressor is running. (As you know.) The relative power loss -- what you feel on the SOTP dyno -- depends on the overall power curve and torque of the engine and efficiency of the compressor.
Even though the compressor in my wife's G20 is similar in size and efficiency, it feels like a boat anchor is dropped out the back of the car when it engages. A 15-horsepower drag on a 145-horsepower engine is, relatively speaking, a huge number when compared with a 15-horsepower drag on a 298-horsepower engine. Her car turns into a 130-horsepower (and in reality much less during a Dallas summer, with the 100-degree ambient heat sapping another 10 or 15 horsepower compared with a 70-degree baseline) slug, while my G35 merely drops to a 283-horsepower slightly-less-speedy rabbit.
And finally, Corgi, as a guy who's owned five Nissan cars over the last 15 years or so intermixed with a Dodge, Oldsmobile, Pontiac and countless rentals, I think that Nissans in general seem to run compressors that put a heavier drag on the engine than many other manufacturers. The G35 is no exception. I've noticed it with every single Nissan I've bought.