I found a 2005 G35 coupe 6 speed 52k miles with navi at the private dealership and they are asking $20k. What would be the best offer that i should give them? i'm thinking $15 but it might be too low.

I didn't go see the car yet but i checked the carfax and it has 2 owners perviously...


Detailed History


Owner 1
Est. length owned:
10/18/05 - 5/14/09
(3 yrs. 6 mo.)


07/11/2005 * Vehicle manufactured and shipped to original dealer

09/08/2005 12 * Pre-delivery inspection completed

10/18/2005 * 85 Title issued or updated First owner reported
Registered as personal vehicle Loan or lien reported

02/27/2006 * 5,513 * Oil and filter changed chassis lubricated
Tire condition and pressure checked
*

Owner 2
Est. length owned:
5/14/09 - 5/19/09
(5 days)


05/14/2009 * 39,125 * Title issued or updated
New owner reported Loan or lien reported

05/19/2009 Online Listing *
Vehicle offered for sale

04/12/2010 *51,131 * Auto Auction *
Sold at auction in Pennsylvania
Listed as a dealer vehicle




Do you guys think owner 2 is a little bit fishy? Bought the car for 5 days (5/14/09 - 5/19/09) and listed online for sale? and the car wasn't sold until at the auto auction recently 4/12/2010 ? Why does it take almost a year for the car to sell and the mileage jump up 10k.

Is it normal?

What do you guys think?

$20k is too high for an '05.. you could easily get one for around 16

i paid 16K for an 04 DG coupe, 6mt, loaded, navi, brembos...46K miles...

For 20k; I would be looking at 06's. That is too high for an 05. I know autotrader does a 'trade-in value' for one's ride and mine (fully loaded 05 6mt with 53k) was coming up to 16k as the high; and that was with nothing wrong with it.

I just think you can get a better deal if you wait.