Hey folks,

Trying to make a car-buying decision here so I'd appreciate being as impartial as possible! The contenders are a '08 G35x and a '10 Legacy 3.6R Limited. 50k and 37k respectively.Can probably get the Infiniti a little cheaper, but it is slightly worse on gas and takes premium, so the cost evens out.

The way I see it, the pros/cons of each:
Infiniti: adds more luxury, more powerful (unnecessarily?), probably pretty reliable. fun to drive. Lots of tech features.

Subaru: Will almost certainly be reliable, comes with CPO warranty, more than adequate acceleration with the 3.6R, I currently have and like a Subaru. A little more storage space.
I think they're probably equally comfortable to sit in.

The one question I have is the ride quality, as I live in Pittsburgh and it is a REALLY bumpy/potholey city, so how it takes these makes a difference to me.

So I'm having a tough time. I like driving both, and the G is probably more fun, but I'm wondering if the Legacy is comparable while also being a bit more practical. But am I giving up a little more luxury for no reason?

Help!

 

G35....

 

You will be happier with the Subaru.

 

I drove a new Legacy with my sister and wasn't a fan.