my guess is that it was underground parking and she might of reversed into a rectangular cement pole that was in her blind spot

 

im gonna say a round pole in an underground parking lot...undergrounds in toronto are notorious for it.

if it were a collision the damage area wouldnt be so concentrated

 

lending your car out to siblings then having them lie about the damage I would make her pay the deductable and the increase in yearly rate just for the fact she lied about it.

 

Agreed

 

that doesnt look like a car mark heh.,.. i dont think ive ever let my sister drive my car.. maybe once when i was in it . gl

 

I love this thread.... CSI style...

If she is younger, teach her a lesson... if she is older.. make her pay

GL with the repair. It doesn't matter who drove it, the car was "parked" right? ... but i'm sure if the insurance company sends a person to check it out... he or she will have a hard time believing there was another vehicle involved.

 

I tried talking to her and she still won't admit to it. I made her go to the Police Collision Centre to file a report. My insurance is most likely going to cover it since I do have full coverage.

 

My younger sister was driving one of my cars once and hit a curb full force. I had to replace a custom Cragar SS Mag and a bent spindle. She couldn't help but fess up about it, the poor kid. I felt so bad for her what could I say.

 

Dude that sucks. Sorry to hear your baby was banged up. I can't help but think that the consensus here is right. Since if it was a one-way and someone would've had to have hit you coming from behind, therefore the scratch would deepen moving towards the front of the car, not vice versa, unless they backed into you - but how would a guy hit you like that unless they were parked on the other side of the street and what kind of one-way has parking on BOTH sides of the street? Or that has to be the saddest parallel park I've ever seen (to have hit you that way).

I'm a solid 'PLUS 1' on the white parking pillar in underground parking.

GL with the claim.

 

I agree cause unfortunately I scratched my G on a round pole in pac and the damage looks very close to yours......

 

Unfortunately for you I think the insurance people are going to take one look at that damage and say "so.....you wanna tell us one more time how this happened"?
If they suspect fraud it won't go well for you. Does your sister understand what kind of trouble she can get you in IF she is lying?
Good luck though.

 

dude for real not to burst ur bubble, but thats EXACTLY wat my x girlfriends car looked like after i scratched the hell outa it driving out of the underground parking lot on richmond after a club....Shes got some explaining to do BIG TIME, and rpm&my_g35 is right bro..explain to her how serious it is if she is lieing cause u will get in some BIG trouble..Insurance fraud is CRAZY!...hope all works out bro

 

Yeah. Just mention to your sister before taking the car in that insurance fraud is not a good thing. Make sure you scare her.

And as many others have said, That definitely looks like some self inflicted damage with a pole or barrier of some sort.

 

Seriously, I don't think most adjusters are that stupid. They will never believe the BS story of a hit and run.
You better be prepared to pay out of pocket.

 

they'll believe it. trust me ive seen pretty messed up claims. its the appraisers you should be worried about.