Which sealant lasts the longest?
#31
Registered User
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: New Orleans ,LA
Posts: 174
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by TheTick
Ok...spent hours and hours at autopia and autogeeks forums and finally went with the Collinite 476 paste wax. It is a bit more work to remove, but after reading tons of posts about it's incredible durability and water beading, I figured it would be worth it.
Applied it with a 4" blue pad which fits perfectly into the tin. Applied a very thin layer with a PC and did the whole car in a few minutes. Let it dry for a few more minutes and it took about 15 minutes to remove. Not nearly as easy as FMJ, but wasn't bad at all. One week later I washed the car and WOW...people weren't kidding when they said it beads like no other. I have never seen water bead like this.
I'll report more about durability later.
Applied it with a 4" blue pad which fits perfectly into the tin. Applied a very thin layer with a PC and did the whole car in a few minutes. Let it dry for a few more minutes and it took about 15 minutes to remove. Not nearly as easy as FMJ, but wasn't bad at all. One week later I washed the car and WOW...people weren't kidding when they said it beads like no other. I have never seen water bead like this.
I'll report more about durability later.
#32
<table border="0" cellpadding="6" cellspacing="0" width="100%"> <tbody><tr> <td class="alt2" style="border: 1px inset ;"> Originally Posted by Braintree
Consumer reports has several reviews and concluded in 2006 that Black Magic Wet Shine, Nu-Finish and Turtle Wax T-6 were the most durable waxes. They were heavily criticized in several car forums. I've used Collinate 845 (more of a sealant than wax) for several years and it will survive 9-12 months and thru the snowy and road salted winters of PA. I used it on a 1971 VW, 1992 Black Volvo and on on a G35 annually and the water beaded even after a year- Zaino, Zymol, and the most expensive waxes faired <2 months in the winter before the bead left. This is a balancing act as durability doesn't always translate into depth of color, gloss and that liquid look.
</td> </tr> </tbody></table>
You must have been asleep in high school when they covered Dale Carnegie's HOW TO WIN FRIENDS AND INFLUENCE PEOPLE book. Not too late, you can buy it at Half.com for about $1.95 plus shipping!
Consumer reports has several reviews and concluded in 2006 that Black Magic Wet Shine, Nu-Finish and Turtle Wax T-6 were the most durable waxes. They were heavily criticized in several car forums. I've used Collinate 845 (more of a sealant than wax) for several years and it will survive 9-12 months and thru the snowy and road salted winters of PA. I used it on a 1971 VW, 1992 Black Volvo and on on a G35 annually and the water beaded even after a year- Zaino, Zymol, and the most expensive waxes faired <2 months in the winter before the bead left. This is a balancing act as durability doesn't always translate into depth of color, gloss and that liquid look.
</td> </tr> </tbody></table>
Originally Posted by superchargedg
I could care less what those people at consumer reports say and would never use anything that is in your post except the 845 wax.
You must have been asleep in high school when they covered Dale Carnegie's HOW TO WIN FRIENDS AND INFLUENCE PEOPLE book. Not too late, you can buy it at Half.com for about $1.95 plus shipping!
#33
Originally Posted by TheTick
Ok...spent hours and hours at autopia and autogeeks forums and finally went with the Collinite 476 paste wax. It is a bit more work to remove, but after reading tons of posts about it's incredible durability and water beading, I figured it would be worth it.........
.
.
Ever wonder what those guys at car shows use to keep their cars so "rich" looking-- it's 3m Imperial Glaze. The problem is that the glaze evaporates within days.... so you seal it immediately with an excellent, long lasting wax (unfortunately, the most expensive waxes, such as MeGuires, Mothers, Zymol and Zaino, etc., tend to be to the least effective for longer term sealing and protection) and this is where the Colinate comes in.
Last edited by Braintree; 12-07-2008 at 06:55 AM.
#35
I went with the 476 instead of the 845 because I found a couple threads where people were told directly by collinite that their 476 paste lasts longer than the 845 liquid . How much longer, I don't know.
Collonite seemed to be the #1 choice for people winterizing their car. Lots of posts about this stuff being impossible to remove wash after wash. I'll keep you guys posted on my personal results.
Collonite seemed to be the #1 choice for people winterizing their car. Lots of posts about this stuff being impossible to remove wash after wash. I'll keep you guys posted on my personal results.
#36
I wanted to show my neighbor the crazy beading and grabbed a water bottle and started spraying the hood. I soon started smelling a strong paint thinner smell and realized I grabbed my mineral spirits bottle and not the water bottle. I immediately wiped it off and assumed that the cleaner would have taken the collinite right off. I then sprayed the same area with water and it still beaded like nothing ever happened. Very impressive!
#37
Originally Posted by TheTick
I wanted to show my neighbor the crazy beading and grabbed a water bottle and started spraying the hood. I soon started smelling a strong paint thinner smell and realized I grabbed my mineral spirits bottle and not the water bottle. I immediately wiped it off and assumed that the cleaner would have taken the collinite right off. I then sprayed the same area with water and it still beaded like nothing ever happened. Very impressive!
So it looks like the Colinate is very effective. I'd be curious if the more expensive waxes (Zymol, Zaino, MCGuire's Mother's, etc.) could handle this demonstration. Great story by the way.
#38
#39
#40
#41
Originally Posted by TheTick
Update...
I think it's been about 4 weeks. 3 car washes and 2 rainy days. This pic really doesn't do it justice. There are GIANT to m&m size beads all over the top of the car. I've never seen anything like it.
I think it's been about 4 weeks. 3 car washes and 2 rainy days. This pic really doesn't do it justice. There are GIANT to m&m size beads all over the top of the car. I've never seen anything like it.
Beading itself is not indicative of protection. Nor is the size of the bead (even giant M&M sized beads).
Bare paint, with nothing on it, will bead water just as good as the best wax/sealant out there. Beading is caused by cleanliness and uniformity of the surface.
Therefore if you are seeing many different size beads, or beading change from one area of the car to the next, it means your wax is starting to wear off.
Beading stops because 1) Water is absorbed into dirt, grime, or other contaminants on the paint. 2) The uneven wear of a wax/sealant creates an uneven surface on the car and prevents water beading. In other words, the surface is not flat and smooth because some places have wax, and others don't.
Tick - Are the beads of water all the same size throughout your car? And do the 'roll off' easily when you start driving?
#42
Thanks for the info Ghaleon. The beads are pretty uniform, but they constantly connect to each other making larger beads. They definately roll off the car even when sitting still. The tiny beads join to make larger beads and then slowly start to roll.
I've always kept my cars pretty clean and never seen beading like this, but what you say also makes sense. The paint also feels very slick to the touch.
I've always kept my cars pretty clean and never seen beading like this, but what you say also makes sense. The paint also feels very slick to the touch.
#43
Originally Posted by TheTick
Thanks for the info Ghaleon. The beads are pretty uniform, but they constantly connect to each other making larger beads. They definately roll off the car even when sitting still. The tiny beads join to make larger beads and then slowly start to roll.
I've always kept my cars pretty clean and never seen beading like this, but what you say also makes sense. The paint also feels very slick to the touch.
I've always kept my cars pretty clean and never seen beading like this, but what you say also makes sense. The paint also feels very slick to the touch.
#44
<table border="0" cellpadding="6" cellspacing="0" width="100%"> <tbody><tr> <td class="alt2" style="border: 1px inset ;"> Originally Posted by Braintree
Consumer reports has several reviews and concluded in 2006 that Black Magic Wet Shine, Nu-Finish and Turtle Wax T-6 were the most durable waxes. They were heavily criticized in several car forums. I've used Collinate 845 (more of a sealant than wax) for several years and it will survive 9-12 months and thru the snowy and road salted winters of PA. I used it on a 1971 VW, 1992 Black Volvo and on on a G35 annually and the water beaded even after a year- Zaino, Zymol, and the most expensive waxes faired <2 months in the winter before the bead left. This is a balancing act as durability doesn't always translate into depth of color, gloss and that liquid look.
</td> </tr> </tbody></table>
You must have been asleep in high school when they covered Dale Carnegie's HOW TO WIN FRIENDS AND INFLUENCE PEOPLE book. Not too late, you can buy it at Half.com for about $1.95 plus shipping!
Consumer reports has several reviews and concluded in 2006 that Black Magic Wet Shine, Nu-Finish and Turtle Wax T-6 were the most durable waxes. They were heavily criticized in several car forums. I've used Collinate 845 (more of a sealant than wax) for several years and it will survive 9-12 months and thru the snowy and road salted winters of PA. I used it on a 1971 VW, 1992 Black Volvo and on on a G35 annually and the water beaded even after a year- Zaino, Zymol, and the most expensive waxes faired <2 months in the winter before the bead left. This is a balancing act as durability doesn't always translate into depth of color, gloss and that liquid look.
</td> </tr> </tbody></table>
You must have been asleep in high school when they covered Dale Carnegie's HOW TO WIN FRIENDS AND INFLUENCE PEOPLE book. Not too late, you can buy it at Half.com for about $1.95 plus shipping!
I read that book in Russian, good information. Treat others how they want to be treated not how you want to be treated
#45
Week 5...
I drive about 100 highway miles a day and it's been raining the last couple days. Car got really dirty and needed a good rub down with bucket full of sudsy turtle wax wash. I would say that it's lost about 30% of it's slickness, but still beads like crazy.
This pic is after wash #4.
I drive about 100 highway miles a day and it's been raining the last couple days. Car got really dirty and needed a good rub down with bucket full of sudsy turtle wax wash. I would say that it's lost about 30% of it's slickness, but still beads like crazy.
This pic is after wash #4.