Automatic Transmission: Drain & Refill vs Flush
#1
Automatic Transmission: Drain & Refill vs Flush
Stats: 03.5 G35 sedan with 42M.
I want to service the transmission but not sure if the flush is necessary. Any insight?
- South Bay, CA Infiniti quoted $160 for Drain & Refill with Matic S.
- Van Nuys, CA Infiniti quoted $260 for the flush with Matic S.
I want to service the transmission but not sure if the flush is necessary. Any insight?
- South Bay, CA Infiniti quoted $160 for Drain & Refill with Matic S.
- Van Nuys, CA Infiniti quoted $260 for the flush with Matic S.
#5
you can do the flush yourself, drain the trans, its about 4qts, fill it ip with 4 qts, take the trans cooler line off the cooler and put it in a 4 qt empty oil jug, have some one run the motor, 2 qts of the old fluid will pump out in 10 seconds or so, add 2 qts, repeat this step a few time and the fluid color will change when the new fluid comes out. check the level and top it off if neede, good to go, thats how its done in the FSM too,
The following users liked this post:
abrecos (02-25-2016)
#7
Castrol Import says it can be used where Matic J is recommended. But most here will likely tell you to use nothing but Matic J (now replaced with Matic S at the dealer.)
I was quoted $16 per quart for Matic S.
I was quoted $16 per quart for Matic S.
Trending Topics
#9
What I did was buy 10 QTs of J-matic (apparently now S-matic) and did three transmission case drains (~3.1 QTs) over the course of 100 miles. This was done last year with about 60K miles on the clock. Now I will do a tranny case fluid replacement (3.1QTs) every summer or about every 10K miles. That should be more the adequate to keep the tranny happy. It's probably way overkill for most autos, but I auto-x/drag race my car so it does get abused more than most.
The following 2 users liked this post by DaveB:
abrecos (10-09-2017),
Tessalynn_G35 (06-21-2015)
#10
#11
I disagree. The flushing machines can actually do more harm than good because these systems pressurize the transmission above typical pressures and can squeeze broken off clutch friction material into areas it shouldn't go. The fluid replacement procedure outlined in the FSM is exactly as MardiGrasMax described. That's how Nissan recommends you do a full fluid replacement.
What I did was buy 10 QTs of J-matic (apparently now S-matic) and did three transmission case drains (~3.1 QTs) over the course of 100 miles. This was done last year with about 60K miles on the clock. Now I will do a tranny case fluid replacement (3.1QTs) every summer or about every 10K miles. That should be more the adequate to keep the tranny happy. It's probably way overkill for most autos, but I auto-x/drag race my car so it does get abused more than most.
What I did was buy 10 QTs of J-matic (apparently now S-matic) and did three transmission case drains (~3.1 QTs) over the course of 100 miles. This was done last year with about 60K miles on the clock. Now I will do a tranny case fluid replacement (3.1QTs) every summer or about every 10K miles. That should be more the adequate to keep the tranny happy. It's probably way overkill for most autos, but I auto-x/drag race my car so it does get abused more than most.
I did my second atf drain last week. I didn't measure it this time and just assume it's 4 quarts each time. Should of measured it. Oh well...
#12
did a drain and fill on my 04 coupe a few weeks ago and at LEAST 5 quarts came out. I was surprised after reading on here most people only get between 3 and 4 out with a drain.
I immediately noticed improvements across the board with the 5AT after getting some fresh fluid in there... I may have been overdue
I immediately noticed improvements across the board with the 5AT after getting some fresh fluid in there... I may have been overdue
The following users liked this post:
Tessalynn_G35 (06-21-2015)
#14
I disagree. The flushing machines can actually do more harm than good because these systems pressurize the transmission above typical pressures and can squeeze broken off clutch friction material into areas it shouldn't go. The fluid replacement procedure outlined in the FSM is exactly as MardiGrasMax described. That's how Nissan recommends you do a full fluid replacement.
What I did was buy 10 QTs of J-matic (apparently now S-matic) and did three transmission case drains (~3.1 QTs) over the course of 100 miles. This was done last year with about 60K miles on the clock. Now I will do a tranny case fluid replacement (3.1QTs) every summer or about every 10K miles. That should be more the adequate to keep the tranny happy. It's probably way overkill for most autos, but I auto-x/drag race my car so it does get abused more than most.
What I did was buy 10 QTs of J-matic (apparently now S-matic) and did three transmission case drains (~3.1 QTs) over the course of 100 miles. This was done last year with about 60K miles on the clock. Now I will do a tranny case fluid replacement (3.1QTs) every summer or about every 10K miles. That should be more the adequate to keep the tranny happy. It's probably way overkill for most autos, but I auto-x/drag race my car so it does get abused more than most.
I agree. I prefer the drain and fill vs a full flush.
I would do it myself though. It's not that hard and maybe $50 in fluids.
#15
This is something I should probably do, too.