To Rebuild or Buy a used motor
#1
To Rebuild or Buy a used motor
I am in between a rock and a hardplace what should I do. with my 03' Sedan
My motor is done - had worsening oil consumption, engine knock and finally gave out at 163K
I have the option to rebuild but I need a new short block and build is extensive - with labor im looking at $7500-$8000
Or do I just drop in a used motor... I just really don't trust a used motor much, It's going to have the same oil consumption problems.
This car is my Daily Driver/Commuter car. How much should just the swap in labor cost about a grand?
and where should I look for a donor motor besides ebay and this forum?
Thanks for the help, I'm freaking out I really didn't want to buy a new car.
My motor is done - had worsening oil consumption, engine knock and finally gave out at 163K
I have the option to rebuild but I need a new short block and build is extensive - with labor im looking at $7500-$8000
Or do I just drop in a used motor... I just really don't trust a used motor much, It's going to have the same oil consumption problems.
This car is my Daily Driver/Commuter car. How much should just the swap in labor cost about a grand?
and where should I look for a donor motor besides ebay and this forum?
Thanks for the help, I'm freaking out I really didn't want to buy a new car.
#2
sounds like a high price rebuild, both have ups and downs...rebuilding ur motor will allow you to add the internals u want,maybe more relaible internals. and doing just a swap you could prob save money..there are used motors all over the web for 3-4k with many less miles..doing the swap is also much easier and can be done in a matter of day's
#3
#7
I've been involved in the installation of 2 used engines-- no problem. The key piece is to know exactly what you're looking for when buying. I bought mine at a salvage yard where you can get the phone # of the previous owner and ask some questions about oil consumption, type of driving they did, did they maintain it well, etc.
Labor was approximately 6-8 hours for a Toyota Camry and around 4 for an older Volvo. Having it done by a competent mechanic in a small town can save you nearly 50% of labor costs. For example, where I am right now, the cost is $92-110 per hour, but just 1 hour away it's $35-45 per hour for the same service and both mechanics are ASC certified.
A rebuild would likely have cost me 30-50% more. A rebuilt, even if done correctly, ensures nothing, just like a used engine ensures nothing. There are new engines that blow and some that last >250K, so there might not be an advantage either way.
The other issue is the high mileage on the car-- it's not just your engine that's high mileage, it's also your suspension, electrical, bearings, tranny, etc. Overall, it's a large investment for something that could begin to nickel and dime you as it nears 190-200K.
It's like a marriage, you don't really know who you've married sometimes until you've been on the "road" together for awhile.
Labor was approximately 6-8 hours for a Toyota Camry and around 4 for an older Volvo. Having it done by a competent mechanic in a small town can save you nearly 50% of labor costs. For example, where I am right now, the cost is $92-110 per hour, but just 1 hour away it's $35-45 per hour for the same service and both mechanics are ASC certified.
A rebuild would likely have cost me 30-50% more. A rebuilt, even if done correctly, ensures nothing, just like a used engine ensures nothing. There are new engines that blow and some that last >250K, so there might not be an advantage either way.
The other issue is the high mileage on the car-- it's not just your engine that's high mileage, it's also your suspension, electrical, bearings, tranny, etc. Overall, it's a large investment for something that could begin to nickel and dime you as it nears 190-200K.
It's like a marriage, you don't really know who you've married sometimes until you've been on the "road" together for awhile.
Last edited by Braintree; 01-04-2010 at 03:44 PM.
Trending Topics
#9
Registered User
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: South Carolina
Posts: 377
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
theres a place in texas that buys used motors from japan with lowish (40k) miles on them and sells and ships for pretty cheap.... bought a honda 4 cyl. engine for $695 shipped within a week. this might be the best bet.... if i'm not mistaken, japan's pollution control on their cars isn't as strict, so you might be able to buy a car with a few more ponies... try a google search to see if you can find the place
#10
G35 engine rebuilt
Look for another shop they charged me 5500 for a engine rebuilt. And labor. Parts 3100 labor 2600. Is better to get it rebuilt because you might get a used engine with less miles but it can also be damaged. For instance maybe the oil gaskets are bad or the rods or bearings are worn out. You never know.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Z1Motorsports
Suspension-Vendor
56
05-31-2020 01:56 PM
Frostbite91
Audio, Video & Electronics
5
08-20-2015 07:20 PM
iknowitsfast
Buying, Selling & Leasing Discussion
6
08-12-2015 02:08 AM