Official "G35driver.com" logo contest
Originally Posted by boro240
Almost all of these are WAY too busy. I actually like the current logo/graphic. It's simple and effective, and looks the most professional. I don't see anything in this thread that's worthy of replacing it. (not to be overly harsh, just my honest opinion)
Registered User
Joined: Aug 2005
Posts: 94
Likes: 0
From: Makakilo, HI
Originally Posted by ABQ_G35
Oh, and who are you?
For future reference, It's called constructive crticism.
Last edited by boro240; Jan 13, 2006 at 08:00 AM.
Registered User
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 80
Likes: 0
Originally Posted by boro240
Im a member and entitled to my opinion on the matter. I also happen to be a graphic design major. No need to get sand in your panties just because my opinion happens to differ. I don't see people who give comments like "real nice dude" getting harassed for throwing their 2 cents in without a submission.
For future reference, It's called constructive crticism.
For future reference, It's called constructive crticism.
I also totally disagree with everything you said.
First of all, nowhere in the contest criteria does it say that this logo will replace the current web site logo, nor does it quantify any design parameters other than it has to include the words "G35 Driver". So, "busy" designs are as welcome as simplistic ones. I would also imagine the reason for being vague is to leave the doors wide open for the artists and therefore encourage creativity.
There are plenty of good, creative design submissions here that could easily replace the current one, if that was or is the goal.
As an artist, I have no problem with those who feel the need to critique my work, in fact I welcome opinions. But it definately means more when it comes from those who appreciate the time and talent required to do it.
So, for future reference, durogatory statements with no basis or blatently rude comments meant to ridicule or inflict hurt are not welcome here and will only place those who submitt them in the same catagory as Boro here.
(Of course, thats just MY opinion.)
Last edited by Reric; Jan 13, 2006 at 09:49 AM.
Guest
Posts: n/a
Ok guys simple question yall might not care or what not bc there is not many girls on here but why not make something for them ya know? Like the whole thing with the g35s being sketched as yall did in the logos make a tshirt or something for a girl with that on there but on the back maybe have something like g35driver.com on the back...in rhinestones or something...bc i know most girls like to be trendy and i think that would be really neat for the girls ya know...or something along that line bc you know girls do LOVE their Gs too...sorry thats oneof my few ideas...im limited guys on my thoughts...SOWWIE!
Registered User
Joined: Aug 2005
Posts: 94
Likes: 0
From: Makakilo, HI
Originally Posted by Reric
Well, I dont think anyone has a problem with constructive criticism but you saying "nothing here is worthy" isnt constuctive. In fact its just plain dumbass criticism. Then revealing that your a "design major" only supports the fact that you have no credible qualification to be judging real artists work, and you are in fact a dumbass.
I also totally disagree with everything you said.
First of all, nowhere in the contest criteria does it say that this logo will replace the current web site logo, nor does it quantify any design parameters other than it has to include the words "G35 Driver". So, "busy" designs are as welcome as simplistic ones. I would also imagine the reason for being vague is to leave the doors wide open for the artists and therefore encourage creativity.
There are plenty of good, creative design submissions here that could easily replace the current one, if that was or is the goal.
As an artist, I have no problem with those who feel the need to critique my work, in fact I welcome opinions. But it definately means more when it comes from those who appreciate the time and talent required to do it.
So, for future reference, durogatory statements with no basis or blatently rude comments meant to ridicule or inflict hurt are not welcome here and will only place those who submitt them in the same catagory as Boro here.
(Of course, thats just MY opinion.)
I also totally disagree with everything you said.
First of all, nowhere in the contest criteria does it say that this logo will replace the current web site logo, nor does it quantify any design parameters other than it has to include the words "G35 Driver". So, "busy" designs are as welcome as simplistic ones. I would also imagine the reason for being vague is to leave the doors wide open for the artists and therefore encourage creativity.
There are plenty of good, creative design submissions here that could easily replace the current one, if that was or is the goal.
As an artist, I have no problem with those who feel the need to critique my work, in fact I welcome opinions. But it definately means more when it comes from those who appreciate the time and talent required to do it.
So, for future reference, durogatory statements with no basis or blatently rude comments meant to ridicule or inflict hurt are not welcome here and will only place those who submitt them in the same catagory as Boro here.
(Of course, thats just MY opinion.)
Registered User
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 9,054
Likes: 3
From: Rio Grande Valley, New Mexico
Originally Posted by boro240
I admit it was harsh. I never said I wasn't or couldn't be a dick. Never-the-less, it was not my intention to be "derogatory" or "blatantly rude". Like I said, I'm a graphics major myself, so I can fully apprreciate the time/effort/talent/whatever taken. There were just certain things that I felt were lacking in most of the submissions, so I made it known. I also said where I thought they could be improved, but I guess that's not constructive?
Last edited by ABQ_G35; Jan 13, 2006 at 10:30 PM.
Registered User
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 80
Likes: 0
Boro,
Please accept my apology for lashing out. It seemed to me you were just...well as you put it, being a dick.
Its just that I have seen it happen so many times in situations like this where negativity spoils enthusiasm. We were going along so good there and then along comes your post and BAM!, the entries trickle to a stop.
Glad to see ABQ bounce back with another excellent piece!
Aestheticmynd has us reeling with anticipation for this so called Pro Logo, and I am going to take your advice and get to work on some simpler designs. Now, here comes the challange.
Lets see what you got dude.
The best way for you to convey your ideas or opinions is to create something on your own.
You have the capability to do so.
Instead of being a critic, take this opportunity to show off your talent.
Please accept my apology for lashing out. It seemed to me you were just...well as you put it, being a dick.
Its just that I have seen it happen so many times in situations like this where negativity spoils enthusiasm. We were going along so good there and then along comes your post and BAM!, the entries trickle to a stop.
Glad to see ABQ bounce back with another excellent piece!
Aestheticmynd has us reeling with anticipation for this so called Pro Logo, and I am going to take your advice and get to work on some simpler designs. Now, here comes the challange.
Lets see what you got dude.
The best way for you to convey your ideas or opinions is to create something on your own.
You have the capability to do so.
Instead of being a critic, take this opportunity to show off your talent.
Last edited by Reric; Jan 16, 2006 at 09:01 AM.
........ and the hits keeps rollin in folks .....
Very nice ppl. Peeps with some serious skillz postin up.
I haven't seen it posted or maybe I missed it but what is the winning logo for ? Is this going to be for the website or for the car?
The reason why I ask is that of the submitted logos, some are nice for the site but I wouldn't put it on my whip and visa versa, if you get my drift.
Keep them coming in......
dyenboy - you deleted my favorite submission at the begining of the thread
...... jk
Very nice ppl. Peeps with some serious skillz postin up.
I haven't seen it posted or maybe I missed it but what is the winning logo for ? Is this going to be for the website or for the car?
The reason why I ask is that of the submitted logos, some are nice for the site but I wouldn't put it on my whip and visa versa, if you get my drift.
Keep them coming in......
dyenboy - you deleted my favorite submission at the begining of the thread
...... jk
