Yet 1 more '07 G35 Sedan test drive from a real Infiniti fan and current driver
Originally Posted by bsgoren
Well, ok, maybe it was stone interior...whatever, it was beige, ok? 

Close enough.
I have been back to drive the 335i twice, and was close to springing for it when I saw a new G in the flesh. To me it is far better looking live than in pics, and the interrior is better in every way than the Bimmer. So I am on hold pending driving the new G. My 02.5 has been the best car I have ever owned. After 68 k miles it has NO rattles and has had no repairs (other than recall brakes early on and normal maintenance).
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 599
Likes: 0
From: South Florida
Originally Posted by chuckg35
I have been back to drive the 335i twice, and was close to springing for it when I saw a new G in the flesh. To me it is far better looking live than in pics, and the interrior is better in every way than the Bimmer. So I am on hold pending driving the new G. My 02.5 has been the best car I have ever owned. After 68 k miles it has NO rattles and has had no repairs (other than recall brakes early on and normal maintenance).
) and my '03 FX35 has also been a pleasure to drive; both without any major issues. However, after you test drive the '07 G35 Sedan, I'd suggest just one more test drive (if you feel you need to) of the BMW 335i Coupe or Sedan (a back-to-back test drive of the G35 Sedan and BMW 335i would be perfect). Then, come back to this thread and tell me if you agree or disagree with my conclusions (in my first post). If you truly haven't made up your mind and if the extra $$ isn't a huge factor, then I'd be very interested in what you have to say.
bsgoren,
I appreciate the thorough evaluation. Having taken up my FX to the dealer today to have it worked on, I know exactly what you mean by "banging" into gear. I was given a fully loaded 04 G35x as a loaner. It is was frustrating to attempt to accelerate and get lag time before the transmission woke up. Very similiar to the FX. It's sad to hear that they didn't really address that. Even with these issues I'm still eager to get out there and take it for a test drive.
I appreciate the thorough evaluation. Having taken up my FX to the dealer today to have it worked on, I know exactly what you mean by "banging" into gear. I was given a fully loaded 04 G35x as a loaner. It is was frustrating to attempt to accelerate and get lag time before the transmission woke up. Very similiar to the FX. It's sad to hear that they didn't really address that. Even with these issues I'm still eager to get out there and take it for a test drive.
Originally Posted by N50
^Hence the name Goofy.


(Yes, yes, old joke, but it never gets old. Just like us G35 enthusiasts!)
I thought the AT was improved in the 07 where the shifts were quicker. I imagine most people who want to shift will just get the manual, like myself. It just seems like it's a lot to ask the transmission to read your mind on when to shift and how quick.
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 599
Likes: 0
From: South Florida
Originally Posted by ABQ_G35
Stone isn't beige, it's gray, so it must have been wheat!

At least I know the ext. color was the light silver...it was very nice. And, of course, as you can see from my 1st post, I certainly remember the test drive itself. Obviously, I thought the details of the test "drive" were the most important for me to remember. Sorry for the confusion...I guess I'm getting older.
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 599
Likes: 0
From: South Florida
Originally Posted by jawjaw
I thought the AT was improved in the 07 where the shifts were quicker. I imagine most people who want to shift will just get the manual, like myself. It just seems like it's a lot to ask the transmission to read your mind on when to shift and how quick.
In contrast, you'd still have to add Gordgee's full 10-wire Grounding Gear kit just to improve the '07 G35 Sedan's MM upshifting, and even then, the BMW 335i's MM (auto) shifting will still be much quicker. As much as Infiniti improved this car for '07, they totally skipped over the tranny, and that was a major mistake, imho. They absolutely should have put in an "all new" 6-speed tranny that shifts quicker and doesn't "bang" into gear. I guess that will have to wait until at least MY '08.
Last edited by bsgoren; Oct 20, 2006 at 11:11 PM.
Originally Posted by GoofyG28
Originally Posted by DaCurryman
A fellow engadget reader?
Comparing a Sedan to a Coupe is not really an even comparison. As Infiniti's bread and butter vehicle, the G35 Sedan was designed for a mainstream, family market compared to the 335i Coupe.
The '08 G35 (G37?) Coupe will be a better comparison to a 335i Coupe.
The '08 G35 (G37?) Coupe will be a better comparison to a 335i Coupe.




