Who's Paid Cash?
I guess this depends on the interest rate of the loan, etc. And, many times, don't you have a choice between a low interest rate, or a rebate? Forgoing the rebate for the lower interest rate sure bumps up the effective payment.
You have to also factor in taxes. A 5% loan, non tax deductible, vs having to earn over 7.5% to even break even. No guarantees on over 7.5%. May go up 20% on stocks, or go down.
In my case, nearly 4 years ago, I put $10K down and financed the rest at 3.4%. Wanted to leave some money in savings for emergencies, so I wouldn't have to go straight to credit cards.
You have to also factor in taxes. A 5% loan, non tax deductible, vs having to earn over 7.5% to even break even. No guarantees on over 7.5%. May go up 20% on stocks, or go down.
In my case, nearly 4 years ago, I put $10K down and financed the rest at 3.4%. Wanted to leave some money in savings for emergencies, so I wouldn't have to go straight to credit cards.
If you have excellent credit you end up with 2% financing and if you have real money in a high yield savings you're better off than putting $35-40k into a car and then get rid of it in a couple of years. You're literally throwing money out the window... but to each their own.
Originally Posted by viguera
I have the money but there's no way I'm eating that depreciation. You can put down $10k and finance the rest if you have good credit. Take the remaining $$$ and put that in a high yield savings over a few years and you end up on top.
Makes absolutely no sense to buy a car outright unless you don't wanna deal with the hassle of the note or you don't care about losing money, or if you're gonna keep the car forever.
Makes absolutely no sense to buy a car outright unless you don't wanna deal with the hassle of the note or you don't care about losing money, or if you're gonna keep the car forever.
Therefore financing = losing more money.
I don't know anyone that keeps a car forever. The scenario I presented holds true if you keep the car for a typical financing period or beyond.
You can probably guess what I chose to do with my car.
Originally Posted by RBull
Whether you pay cash or or finance you "eat the depreciation" all cars have. With financing you also eat the interest charges. I don't know about where you are but here "high yield savings" are lower than a good loan rate or even a secured credit line. Your interest income will also be considered taxable, reducing your real return.
But like I said, to each their own... I put down $10k on this car but not a dime on the Maxima I had before, but $17k on the Benz that I just paid off in December. I look at where my money is, where my credit situation is and pull the trigger... some people might do better or worse, so whatever works for you.
Originally Posted by viguera
I've known people that have 1.9% interest rates -- or better on financed cars... and by high yield I mean "real" high yield... 4-5 year jumbo CDs with $100k on deposit or more.
But like I said, to each their own... I put down $10k on this car but not a dime on the Maxima I had before, but $17k on the Benz that I just paid off in December. I look at where my money is, where my credit situation is and pull the trigger... some people might do better or worse, so whatever works for you.
But like I said, to each their own... I put down $10k on this car but not a dime on the Maxima I had before, but $17k on the Benz that I just paid off in December. I look at where my money is, where my credit situation is and pull the trigger... some people might do better or worse, so whatever works for you.
I have the money but there's no way I'm eating that depreciation. You can put down $10k and finance the rest if you have good credit. Take the remaining $$$ and put that in a high yield savings over a few years and you end up on top.
Makes absolutely no sense to buy a car outright unless you don't wanna deal with the hassle of the note or you don't care about losing money, or if you're gonna keep the car forever.
Makes absolutely no sense to buy a car outright unless you don't wanna deal with the hassle of the note or you don't care about losing money, or if you're gonna keep the car forever.
Good luck with the G.
Originally Posted by Vicg35
why wouldnt you just invest your money instead?



