I've had my 5at G in Chicago for the last 3 weeks and love it.

You can geet some good upgrades for the 5at too, valve body torque converter, etc. the Manumatic is a good time. A few upgrades under the hood and your 5at will be at the 6mt numbers.

No regrets at all. Especially after I read about the clutch/tranny gripes with the 6MT.

im with mikestarr. would've gotten an mt but didn't have a choice at the time. cant really complain though, its still an awesome transmission and i still love the car.

zero regrets. Love how smooth the AT is. I can pick my gear with my right foot.


Gc

Get a 2000 to 3000 dollar beater car for traffic. Get the 6MT!

Somedays I do, Most I thank the lord I can move that little stick over to the side and no worry about shifting

If i was using the car for the commute, I'd get the 5AT.
I hate driving MT to work and back. MT's are for weekend fun.
I have a Civic that's an AT for the commute.

get stick..........you will regret it if you dont

I have a 5AT, I wouldn't mind a 6speed manual at all. But, I see a lot more manual transmissions being replaced than 5AT's. To have one of each would be the best of both worlds.......

I have an AT and it's my daily driver i think it's great...Now I did take it on a rally with some of the Houston members this past weekend and granted it wasn't as quick as the 6MTs in the group but i don't care besides i got it to 120mph i think i'm happy ....Also, I like the comfort of relaxing during traffic and not having to up shift and down shift...

I just got my 05 AT and I love it.. I have a 2001 6MT SLk 320..... no different in fun to me...No matter which one you get, you'll still look good driving it home!

I like the 5AT- It is still fun to driver in MM. At firstI thought that having a 6MT would be nbetter. I am actually happy that I got the 5AT seeing all tyhe issues with the 6MT tranny, and considering how fun the 5AT is to drive..

i drove the the 2003-2004 AT loaners and they were pretty boring.. when I drove the 2005 loaner, it was a much better drive over all. rev-matching auto tranny is pretty cool but i would never trade it for my 6mt. auto tranny still shifts slow in manual mode. I like being in control of the car.

Keep in mind that the 6mt is a grand cheaper than an equally equipped 5at Reading through all the responses, it makes me think about how spoiled we are in this country. Where I come from traffic is so bad that a 20 mile commute takes 2 hours, and people have only one choice as far as transmission. It's called standard.

I own a 5AT, and thought about trading in for a 6MT. After test driving the 6MT, I've realized the auto is for me. I love the ability to drive in traffic without roadrage, but yet being able to smack the stick to the right and be in control of every gear. I love the automatic downshift once I mash the pedal, and I love downshifting whenever I want.

Automatic transmissions of yester-year left a bad rep for these new cars...especially the G35. These new cars DO NOT have the automatics of your old car, they're made to perform! Some new automatics shift faster than manual tranny's. When I tell someone it's an auto, they sound like they're dissappointed...They'll be dissappointed when this "automatic" hands their a$$ to them!