I got a 04 5AT twilight blue G with premium package and 18" wheels with 12k miles and little bit dents on the hood and front bumper (others are perfect). One of my neighbor has a 03 Z track with 8k miles and excellent condition.

I am considering to trade with him and so does him cause his wife hates to drive manual. And im in the market of trading in my car for a 6mt G or Z.

What do u guys think? Is this a fair deal?

i believe the G35 cost a few grand more... so hmmm
also if you think the G35's cabin is noisy the 350z will be MUCH worse...
just a factor to consider. And if u need the small backseats.

Other than that both great cars...

I personaly wouldnt do it.
From what I have seen and talking with a few dealerships around Columbus, the Nissan doesnt have near the re-sale value that the Infiniti does. Many of the local dealerships have the Z for sale on their lots (most for $26k and under), where I think there was only 2 G35 coupes for sale, and both of those were for over $30k.

But then again its your car therefore its your call.

Once I went near luxury, I never go back.

his 350z in excellent condition is worth about $28700 on kbb, even less in good condition at about $27000. your 2004 coupe in only good condition is priced at $31125 and $32975 in excellent condition. now, kbb pricing is a bit off for the coupe. but bottom line, i dont think it's a good deal.