Indecision; G vs. Z
Guest
Posts: n/a
Indecision; G vs. Z
I don't mean to kick a dead horse but I'm gonna anyway. I'm about to buy a new ride and it has come down to either the G35 or the Z.
Right now I'm driving a 95 Golf with racing suspension so I don't mind a harsh ride. I test drove the Z and found that contrary to what I had read the ride was not too bumpy at all. At one point I was doing 90 in the highway and didn' t even realize until the salesman told me in a sort of nervous tone "you do realize you're doing 90, right?" I have not driven the G yet so I'll trust what the reviews say.
1. I am much more attracted to the exterior of the Z but the G is not bad at all, people really appreciate it.
2. On the interior I am torn, the interior of the Z is good.. great. Seats are comfortable and the view to the outside is not bad at all but what's up with the power outlet in the back panel??? Don't they have radar detectors in Japan?!?! The G also has supportive seats, the interior is more refined and much more practical (don't really care about the G's center console though, I've heard about people accidentally scratching the finish and ending up with a brand new scratched center console).
3. The G will allow you to have your leather seats, Bose stereo system AND Brembo breaks where as in the Z the breaks are only available in the Track model (no leather, no bose system)
Now to the questrions:
1. Do both cars use the same suspension??
2. Does the G also come with the limited-slip differential?
3. I've read somewhere that the hood will get mangled by road debri since it is aluminum. Is this true? (This goes for both cars I was just wandering if it was worth buying a carbon fiber hood)
4. I've heard about problems with G manual transmissions is this common? Does the Z has the same problem?
5. I've also heard about the G stalling all of the sudden and then turning back on like nothing happened.
5. Any problems with the Z's window automatic roll-up and down mechanism?
I am going to be using this car as my daily driver in Miami, so I don't have to worry about all that winter crap. I will get married soon but have no children so the back seat is not vital but it would be nice and practical to have one. Also the G will have a glass moon-roof, again not a vital feature but something a welcomed one. My current ride doesn't have one so is not like I will be missing it.
Thank you very much for your help
The road to happiness is riden on faaaaast cars
Right now I'm driving a 95 Golf with racing suspension so I don't mind a harsh ride. I test drove the Z and found that contrary to what I had read the ride was not too bumpy at all. At one point I was doing 90 in the highway and didn' t even realize until the salesman told me in a sort of nervous tone "you do realize you're doing 90, right?" I have not driven the G yet so I'll trust what the reviews say.
1. I am much more attracted to the exterior of the Z but the G is not bad at all, people really appreciate it.
2. On the interior I am torn, the interior of the Z is good.. great. Seats are comfortable and the view to the outside is not bad at all but what's up with the power outlet in the back panel??? Don't they have radar detectors in Japan?!?! The G also has supportive seats, the interior is more refined and much more practical (don't really care about the G's center console though, I've heard about people accidentally scratching the finish and ending up with a brand new scratched center console).
3. The G will allow you to have your leather seats, Bose stereo system AND Brembo breaks where as in the Z the breaks are only available in the Track model (no leather, no bose system)
Now to the questrions:
1. Do both cars use the same suspension??
2. Does the G also come with the limited-slip differential?
3. I've read somewhere that the hood will get mangled by road debri since it is aluminum. Is this true? (This goes for both cars I was just wandering if it was worth buying a carbon fiber hood)
4. I've heard about problems with G manual transmissions is this common? Does the Z has the same problem?
5. I've also heard about the G stalling all of the sudden and then turning back on like nothing happened.
5. Any problems with the Z's window automatic roll-up and down mechanism?
I am going to be using this car as my daily driver in Miami, so I don't have to worry about all that winter crap. I will get married soon but have no children so the back seat is not vital but it would be nice and practical to have one. Also the G will have a glass moon-roof, again not a vital feature but something a welcomed one. My current ride doesn't have one so is not like I will be missing it.
Thank you very much for your help
The road to happiness is riden on faaaaast cars
Registered User
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 596
Likes: 0
From: Ventura, Southern California USA
Re: Indecision; G vs. Z
From what I've read I think I got a pretty clear idea of what car you're gonna get....LOL Good luck with your future Z. Right now I'm in a co-worker's Z. We switch car's every other day or so...lol Because we like each other's cars hehehe... Either or I like both rides. No problems with either or =) Once again good luck!!
Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 30,341
Likes: 9
From: Cambridge, Ont. Canada
Re: Indecision; G vs. Z
The suspension I believe is similar on both cars but a little more comfortable on the G, probably the extra 200lbs.
LSD on all G-coupes
Aluminum hood is fine. Carbon Firbre not worth the $$$$
No more issues with the G M/T's than the Z's.
Stalling problem sounds like the issue Injen had recently with their new CAI. I believe it's rectified now tho.
Don't know of window issues on the Z but heard of only a few on the G that had a problem with the last 1/4 inch when door closed.
Both cars are nice but I love my G. And the warranty is better on the G (4 yrs) as opposed to 3 on the Z.
<font color=green>GSM</font color=green>
LSD on all G-coupes
Aluminum hood is fine. Carbon Firbre not worth the $$$$
No more issues with the G M/T's than the Z's.
Stalling problem sounds like the issue Injen had recently with their new CAI. I believe it's rectified now tho.
Don't know of window issues on the Z but heard of only a few on the G that had a problem with the last 1/4 inch when door closed.
Both cars are nice but I love my G. And the warranty is better on the G (4 yrs) as opposed to 3 on the Z.
<font color=green>GSM</font color=green>
Re: Indecision; G vs. Z
The z is a great car but the g is better
Just look at the interior how much space is in the g and with the i feel alot more comfortable ..
Speed is not a issue the pretty are the exact 1/4mile time so it is what ever suits you..
Just look at the interior how much space is in the g and with the i feel alot more comfortable ..
Speed is not a issue the pretty are the exact 1/4mile time so it is what ever suits you..
Registered User
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 1,178
Likes: 0
From: New Jersey, Hudson County
Re: Indecision; G vs. Z
I never even looked at the Z when i bough my G. 2 weeks ago when I was getting my complimentary oil change from Infiniti i walked over to the Nissan dealership to take a look at the Z. Well ... I havent missed anything. The interior is poor and cheap in comparison to the G's, very small. The exterior does look nice. All in all I am glad I got the G and didnt even waste time to look at the Z while shopping for the new car.
Trending Topics
Registered User
Joined: Mar 2003
Posts: 357
Likes: 0
Re: Indecision; G vs. Z
When you take your car in for service, even oil changes, Would you like to have a Nice G35 Sedan Loaner Car? If Yes, Then go with the GCoupe. If you like public transportation, relying on friends and family to pick up and drop you off, or a courtesy shuttle...go with the Z. That was my main decidieng factor, that and the sunroof, better appointed interior, backseat (for when ya do)..and just the Infiniti Badge..not to mention that I love skylines..and just to think that I own a detuned, n/a car that in a far off land is called a "Skyline"...I had to get it. We have Z's here..But no Skylines. Till now.
"Dont start none, won't be none"
"Dont start none, won't be none"
Re: Indecision; G vs. Z
Considering the name of this site is G35 DRIVER. It may be hard to get an unbiased opinion.
As stated above, with the G you will get a better warranty, loaner car for repairs, a back seat and a larger (nicer) interior. Everything else is just a matter of your personal opinion.
As stated above, with the G you will get a better warranty, loaner car for repairs, a back seat and a larger (nicer) interior. Everything else is just a matter of your personal opinion.
Registered User
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 5,946
Likes: 1
From: San Diego, CA
Re: Indecision; G vs. Z
A loaner for repairs that require 2 hours of labor or more.
Unless your particular dealer gives you extra perks.
2003.5 G35 Sedan Desert Platinum/Graphite Premium/Sport/Aero/Nav/Winter
Unless your particular dealer gives you extra perks.
2003.5 G35 Sedan Desert Platinum/Graphite Premium/Sport/Aero/Nav/Winter
Registered User
Joined: Dec 2002
Posts: 1,606
Likes: 0
From: Texas
Re: Indecision; G vs. Z
it's a difficult decision, but really depends on your priorities.. the Z and G have so many great qualities... personally, space and service mean a lot to me.. the Z would be great because it's such a beautiful car but so is the G.. so, practically speaking, weighing the good/bad for each.. the G just has more "good" associated with it.. basically extra features you may not think about but may want in the future.. good luck in deciding.. you won't be making a mistake with either of them, IMO.
'03 G35 Sedan: ivory/aero body/sport/sunroof
Warning: Objects in mirror are FASTER than they appear
'03 G35 Sedan: ivory/aero body/sport/sunroof
Warning: Objects in mirror are FASTER than they appear
Registered User
Joined: Mar 2003
Posts: 174
Likes: 0
From: Philly Metro
Re: Indecision; G vs. Z
Both cars are winners! It's such a close call, that based on your preference for the Z's styling alone, I'd say just go with that one. Plus, there may be better availability on the Z, especially if you want a manual tranny.
For me, here were the factors that tipped it in the G's favor:
- available glass sunroof
- back seatlets
- more overall luggage space for weekend getaways for 2
- I <font color=red>love</font color=red> that gorgeous G styling!
- didn't personally care as much for the Z's styling
Those factors made it easy for me, so you likewise just have to decide what's most important to you. Good luck with your decision.
<font color=blue>2003 G35 Coupe 6MT - diamond graphite / graphite leather - premium - nav</font color=blue>
For me, here were the factors that tipped it in the G's favor:
- available glass sunroof
- back seatlets
- more overall luggage space for weekend getaways for 2
- I <font color=red>love</font color=red> that gorgeous G styling!
- didn't personally care as much for the Z's styling
Those factors made it easy for me, so you likewise just have to decide what's most important to you. Good luck with your decision.
<font color=blue>2003 G35 Coupe 6MT - diamond graphite / graphite leather - premium - nav</font color=blue>
Registered User
Joined: Mar 2003
Posts: 357
Likes: 0
Re: Indecision; G vs. Z
Really Ryoken? I didn't know that..They give me loaner cars for anything I get done..even oil changes...Maybe My dealer is just giving me some extra perks,,or maybe they are just nicer and have a better service approach. Every dealer is individually owned and operated, Like a franchise. But more liberally detached from the manufacturer. However, my family has spent a few hundred G's at our particular dealership, so that might have something to do with it. Its a Mercedes/Infinit Dealership so....Hot Doggity...
Keep On Keepin On!
"Dont start none, won't be none"
Keep On Keepin On!
"Dont start none, won't be none"
Registered User
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 821
Likes: 1
From: California
Re: Indecision; G vs. Z
Hey GSEDANMAN, I thought only the 6MT's with the sport package came with the LSD? For GTORRES44 I would go with the G man. I mean your gonna get a biased opinion here but it depends on your priorities. I think the G is much more liveable sports coupe. I checked out both first and feel that if you get the 6MT G35 it's a much better value. You get all the stuff on the track edition 350z plus better interior, moonroof, and a back seat. Believe it or not that 2 + 2 will actually effect your insurance rate too. I got a higher quote for the 350z track then for my G35 6MT. I think it's because the 350z is a 2 seater. Also the interior in the z is just a little cheap looking as well. Also from what I've seen they have "almost" the same performacen specs. One of the things I can say even though it's blasphemy here is that I like the 350z exterior just alittle more than the G. Also the 350z comes with focussed beam HID's instead of the reflector type like the G35. Just some of my thoughts, the main thing for me again was the value and quality of the over all package, the G had it for me. Peace. [img]/w3timages/icons/laugh.gif[/img]
-Jason
Laser Red '03 6MT
-Jason
Laser Red '03 6MT
