Will larger wheels and tires affect the performance of my G?
#16
Originally Posted by RJsd7
but i thought samson pwns delilah
#17
Originally Posted by Samson
Nickk6: I see that you have Volk wheels in the 19" size. Are they lighter than the stock 17s that come with Sedan with sports tuned suspension?
I may end up getting a different wheel if I can find a 19" wheel that is similar in weight to the 17". Thanks for the help.
I may end up getting a different wheel if I can find a 19" wheel that is similar in weight to the 17". Thanks for the help.
My 19" volks weigh about 20 lbs for the rear rims and 19 for the fronts. If you get any volk wheel that is forged in 18 or 19", they will most likely weigh less than an oem wheel.
#18
The rims could be lighter than the 17s, but the what about the tires? Tires are usually much heavier than the rims, especially low profile tires due to their super thick sidewalls.
Also, moment of inertia is much higher with a larger rim because the mass is further from the hub. The overall weight could be the same, but the moment of inertia will be quite a bit higher.
Finally, wider rims/tires create more drag, aerodynamic and frictional.
Going from the OEM 17" setup to a typical wide 19" setup will probably make the car 0.2 seconds and 1.5mph slower in the 1/4 mile. Maybe even worse.
Traction will be harder to come by too. Wide low profile tires are great for lateral G's, but they suck for straightline grip due to the wide, but narrow contact patch. A G35 sedan on light 17X8 rims with street-based auto-x spec rubber will run circles around a G35 sedan on 19X8.5 rims and sticky summer rated rubber.
Also, moment of inertia is much higher with a larger rim because the mass is further from the hub. The overall weight could be the same, but the moment of inertia will be quite a bit higher.
Finally, wider rims/tires create more drag, aerodynamic and frictional.
Going from the OEM 17" setup to a typical wide 19" setup will probably make the car 0.2 seconds and 1.5mph slower in the 1/4 mile. Maybe even worse.
Traction will be harder to come by too. Wide low profile tires are great for lateral G's, but they suck for straightline grip due to the wide, but narrow contact patch. A G35 sedan on light 17X8 rims with street-based auto-x spec rubber will run circles around a G35 sedan on 19X8.5 rims and sticky summer rated rubber.
Last edited by DaveB; 10-17-2006 at 05:51 PM.
#19
It depends heavily on what you are looking for:
1) Look
2) Handling, i.e. Skipad
3) Straight line Acceleration
Just like what Dave has said, alot of people have forgot about moment of inertia when they go with bigger rims (bigger means larger diameter as well as width).
Edit: Moment of Inertia is proportional to the square of the radius multiplied by Mass and a constant that depends on the mass distribution... In a nutshell, a larger rim of the same mass would require a larger Force to accelerate when compared a smaller rim of the same mass
Anyhow, i would say just don't go too big and too wide; you should be really happy with your new setup =)
1) Look
2) Handling, i.e. Skipad
3) Straight line Acceleration
Just like what Dave has said, alot of people have forgot about moment of inertia when they go with bigger rims (bigger means larger diameter as well as width).
Edit: Moment of Inertia is proportional to the square of the radius multiplied by Mass and a constant that depends on the mass distribution... In a nutshell, a larger rim of the same mass would require a larger Force to accelerate when compared a smaller rim of the same mass
Anyhow, i would say just don't go too big and too wide; you should be really happy with your new setup =)
Last edited by godmans; 10-18-2006 at 12:57 AM.
#20
Originally Posted by DaveB
The rims could be lighter than the 17s, but the what about the tires? Tires are usually much heavier than the rims, especially low profile tires due to their super thick sidewalls.
Also, moment of inertia is much higher with a larger rim because the mass is further from the hub. The overall weight could be the same, but the moment of inertia will be quite a bit higher.
Finally, wider rims/tires create more drag, aerodynamic and frictional.
Going from the OEM 17" setup to a typical wide 19" setup will probably make the car 0.2 seconds and 1.5mph slower in the 1/4 mile. Maybe even worse.
Traction will be harder to come by too. Wide low profile tires are great for lateral G's, but they suck for straightline grip due to the wide, but narrow contact patch. A G35 sedan on light 17X8 rims with street-based auto-x spec rubber will run circles around a G35 sedan on 19X8.5 rims and sticky summer rated rubber.
Also, moment of inertia is much higher with a larger rim because the mass is further from the hub. The overall weight could be the same, but the moment of inertia will be quite a bit higher.
Finally, wider rims/tires create more drag, aerodynamic and frictional.
Going from the OEM 17" setup to a typical wide 19" setup will probably make the car 0.2 seconds and 1.5mph slower in the 1/4 mile. Maybe even worse.
Traction will be harder to come by too. Wide low profile tires are great for lateral G's, but they suck for straightline grip due to the wide, but narrow contact patch. A G35 sedan on light 17X8 rims with street-based auto-x spec rubber will run circles around a G35 sedan on 19X8.5 rims and sticky summer rated rubber.
#21
Originally Posted by godmans
It depends heavily on what you are looking for:
1) Look
2) Handling, i.e. Skipad
3) Straight line Acceleration
Just like what Dave has said, alot of people have forgot about moment of inertia when they go with bigger rims (bigger means larger diameter as well as width). As many of us might know, moment of inertia is proportional to the square of rotational speed....
Anyhow, i would say just don't go too big and too wide; you should be really happy with your new setup =)
1) Look
2) Handling, i.e. Skipad
3) Straight line Acceleration
Just like what Dave has said, alot of people have forgot about moment of inertia when they go with bigger rims (bigger means larger diameter as well as width). As many of us might know, moment of inertia is proportional to the square of rotational speed....
Anyhow, i would say just don't go too big and too wide; you should be really happy with your new setup =)
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
carid
Wheels & Tires-Vendor
0
07-20-2015 08:57 AM