As a proud owner of a 2004.5 G35 sedan leather model I like to compare my car to the 2001-2003 BMW E39 model 5 series. I noticed that the ride quality my not feel as heavy as the BMW but in comfort it is not to far behind espically in cornering. My family also ownes a 2002 BMW 525i and comparing the two i noticed the G has flatter cornering and a lighter and quicker steering. Interior wise the BMW does have a nicer interior but it did cost us 11K more when comparing the two from new. Also wanted to add the a 90-91 BMW E34 model M5 has about the same performance numbers as the G. Anyone have any thoughts on this. I really would like your input. by the way please feel free to write about this subject a lot since i am very intrested in what EVERYONE thinks Thanks

 

My previous car was a 540 6speed. The G 35 feels more lively, tossable, and perhaps has more lateral grip, but not by much. The 540 has a superior combination of ride and handling, is quite a bit faster in a straight line (while returning about the same fuel economy as the G), has a smoother engine, and is much quieter. It is better in almost every respect. Of course, it should be because it is double the price. I really think the G35 is more comparable to a 3 series. It also breaks down a lot....as far as total ownership experience goes I like the G35 better.

 

Both are way different cars, can't compare. You are stupid, enough said.

 

Cook and brownies are right. If you're comparing, compare the G35 to the 330i.

If you want to compare a car to the 5-series, compare the new M45 when it comes out to the 545i.

 

look at all the stats from dimensions to performance to interior room. for the inline 6 models, I think your the one who is stupid LOL. The G35 is to big next to a 3 series and about the same size as the E39 BMW inline 6 models. Besides who cares this is for fun, negative comments like yours are petty so please stay away LOL.....LOSER

<P ID="edit"><FONT class="small"><EM>Edited by boyoboy78 on 09/07/04 12:56 PM.</EM></FONT></P>

 

Then you're the loser because the 5 series will always win against the G35! Why do the comparison? That BMW is better in almost every way.

Which it SHOULD be because it's in a different class. Dumbass.

 

Want to add: I'm not talking down to the G35. I'm getting ready to spend my $30,000+ on one - you bet I think it's good.

 

Well We own both a G35 and a 5 series and as an owner of both cars I can surely tell you that the E39 Model 5 is not much better then a G35, plus is it did cost 11k more I would hope it is a little better. there are some areas in which the G is better then the 5 and there are other areas in which the 5 is better then the G. as i said they are not to different except in price. I think you should do your reasearch a little better Buddy. by the way what's your problem??

 

no problem, boyoboy. Just expressing my opinion and participating in the discussion. Sorry that I disagreed with you, but sometimes that happens.

 

No problem i do like peoples opnions but not when someone says something down to me LOL its all good

 

I haven't owned a 540/545, but I have smoked them in the corners, straights, from a roll, from a start, etc... and that is without nitrous. I have sat inside and the interior is nice, but it doesn't seem that much bigger than a G. I like the interior of my car better than the 545 (6MT sedan: interior is black with aluminum trim). However, I don't think the G's with the tan interior or those that come with an automatic look better than the 545's interior. Just my 2 cents. I am sure there are some electronic features and the quietness that is better than the G, but I happen to like how my G growls and dont mind being without those electronics. The G fits me just fine. I don't think I would get that car if I was going to spend the extra $$$. Now the new M5 is a different story.

’03 G35S 6MT, black/black:
-Zex n20 Kit 150-shot & Bottle Opener
-Amsoil Air/Oil Filters & Oil
-Digital Nitrous Pressure Gauge & A/F Switch/Gauge
-Pressure-based Bottle Warmer
-MSD Window Switch

 

As the previous ovwner of several BMW's and current owner of a 540 and G35 coupe, I have an opinion on this subject!

The BMW 5 series is a way more refined car in every respect over the G's.They do almost everying perfectly. However, the G's have a higher fun factor, more sportiness, and more power than the 325's 330's, 525's and 530's. The G and the 540 have about the same power. And of course the G does all of this for thousand less.
As others have pointed out though, even though the G's are similar size to the 5 series, they really are only comparable to the 3 series. The 5 series is just so much more refined and luxurious then the G it really is not comparable.

 

Boyoboy78:

I understand the need to compare the two cars. But, they are totally different animals. I don't think anyone who has the money for a 540 would buy a G35 over the BMW. When the new M45 comes out, is it fair to compare the G35 to it? I don't think so!!!

03.5 G35S 5AT - Desert Platinum/Graphite/350Z Tube/Clear corners/HG kit/20% Tint

 

I'd like to chime in on this too.I own an '04 545i and a G35 sedan that i just got a month ago.While the G35 is a very fine machine it does not compare to a 5 series(at least not to a 545).The Bimmer does everything perfect and better than the G.....acceleration,cornering more back room,braking...but like i said there is no better buy for the buck than the G sedan or coupe.

Just my 2 cents.