I've never tried any other clay bar, but I've tried The turtle wax ICE liquid clay bar, and the turtle wax ICE polymer polish/wax. It seems to work well, but I dont know if there is actually something to concieve better results. Also, daily I spray Meguiars Ultimate Spray Detailer(in the black bottle) and wipe with my microfiber. Wheels too. If there is a better way to clean my car with little effort like I am using let me know !