UR Crank Pulley: The Final Word
#167
i'll throw in my 2cents with my experiences with the udp on my 4th gen maxima. i felt that it did help with engine response. in terms of actual 1/4mi performance there are many factors in getting quicker times, but for what it's worth i personally believe the pulley is good for hundreths of a second on ave for those looking for that personal best. there are other things you can lighten which can yield more dramatic changes like wheels and flywheels. this mod should be one the last to get. improved engine breathing and ecu tuning offers more bang for the buck. i wonder what the privateer jdm engineers do in terms to fine tuning VQ performance especially those doing top speed runs in the VQ35DE.
#168
Originally Posted by DaveB
If these things are so great, why are the gains so minimal? Making a gain 2-5hp from 2000-5000rpms isn't going to do much for your 1/4 mile because most of your accelerating is spent above 4500rpms.
#170
Originally Posted by VQdriver
i wonder what the privateer jdm engineers do in terms to fine tuning VQ performance especially those doing top speed runs in the VQ35DE.
#171
#173
Originally Posted by luongdmd
just put on my crank pulley...... love it... car feels lighter, rpm is quicker, feels like the car has a lot less lag.......i love it...
#174
Originally Posted by MechEE
The engine will certainly rev quicker, in neutral. But in gear, there is virtually zero effect (assuming your pulley is just lightened, not underdrive). Sorry, it's all in your head. But as long as you THINK it's better, that's all that really matters, right?
#175
#176
#178
Originally Posted by caelric
That all depends on who you ask.
Me personally, I think it is worth the money, and installing it yourself is a good way to learn more about your engine.
Dave
Me personally, I think it is worth the money, and installing it yourself is a good way to learn more about your engine.
Dave
But if a quicker revving engine in neutral is something you want, and don't mind the downsides of a likely lower engine life, then it may be worth it to you. Heck, if someone could hypnotize me and convince me that my car was faster, I'd probably pay $200+ too.
#179
Really? Thats interesting. "Fact" must mean something else in your dictionary.
I've seen dyno sheets that show more power, and I've seen dyno sheets that show nothing. I know in my 300ZXTT I had a dyno sheet that showed gains of +10 hp and +8 ft-lb's throughout the rpm range. Of course, we all know that dyno sheets can be adjusted quite easily.
It's definitely debateable whether it "frees up" power or not. My opinion is that anything that decreases parasitic loss by being both lighter, and underdriving the accessories is going to work. You are welcome to believe anything you want, but I'd certainly be careful before calling something a "fact"
Dave
I've seen dyno sheets that show more power, and I've seen dyno sheets that show nothing. I know in my 300ZXTT I had a dyno sheet that showed gains of +10 hp and +8 ft-lb's throughout the rpm range. Of course, we all know that dyno sheets can be adjusted quite easily.
It's definitely debateable whether it "frees up" power or not. My opinion is that anything that decreases parasitic loss by being both lighter, and underdriving the accessories is going to work. You are welcome to believe anything you want, but I'd certainly be careful before calling something a "fact"
Dave
#180
Originally Posted by caelric
Really? Thats interesting. "Fact" must mean something else in your dictionary.
I've seen dyno sheets that show more power, and I've seen dyno sheets that show nothing. I know in my 300ZXTT I had a dyno sheet that showed gains of +10 hp and +8 ft-lb's throughout the rpm range. Of course, we all know that dyno sheets can be adjusted quite easily.
It's definitely debateable whether it "frees up" power or not. My opinion is that anything that decreases parasitic loss by being both lighter, and underdriving the accessories is going to work. You are welcome to believe anything you want, but I'd certainly be careful before calling something a "fact"
Dave
I've seen dyno sheets that show more power, and I've seen dyno sheets that show nothing. I know in my 300ZXTT I had a dyno sheet that showed gains of +10 hp and +8 ft-lb's throughout the rpm range. Of course, we all know that dyno sheets can be adjusted quite easily.
It's definitely debateable whether it "frees up" power or not. My opinion is that anything that decreases parasitic loss by being both lighter, and underdriving the accessories is going to work. You are welcome to believe anything you want, but I'd certainly be careful before calling something a "fact"
Dave
But even if you're scared of the math, just use some intuition. Imagine your big massive car (3500+ pounds). Now imagine the acceleration you feel from your original engine configuration. Now take your small little 10 pound crank pulley and remove a couple pounds. Do you really think that this is going to free up so much power that you're going to FEEL a change in acceleration of your massive car? Ridiculous.
Dyno to dyno variations, temperature changes, etc account for any dyno evidence of purely lightened crank pullies. Lightened flywheels free up some noticeable power in 1st and 2nd gear due to the large changes in inertia (big diameters, big mass changes), but even lightened flywheels make little to no power in the higher gears once engine acceleration gets small enough.