Yet another Headlight post...
#16
Join Date: May 2017
Location: Washington State
Posts: 14,809
Received 2,465 Likes
on
2,157 Posts
Coupe 6MT Premium RAS
#18
I lost my first lip spoiler on my SL fooling around with factory HID's. So, thanks but no thanks. Ask yourself, why is Honda LED only from Accord to NSX? As a matter of fact: The Accord never had one HID in it lol; Honda gave you a hint. There is CREE and Phillips and they have chips that yield different results. Each generation of chips is brighter and better and can be built with purpose. Hids are technology that will have limited development.
Now let's talk maintenance; I do not fancy removing tires and linings to get at those HID bulbs when they get tired. They don't seem to last much longer than HIDs. Leds are projected to last 7years with continuous use. Sometimes #2 is really expensive and really bad. Changes come whether or not everyone's research supports it...
https://carcaretotal.com/led-vs-hid/
Now let's talk maintenance; I do not fancy removing tires and linings to get at those HID bulbs when they get tired. They don't seem to last much longer than HIDs. Leds are projected to last 7years with continuous use. Sometimes #2 is really expensive and really bad. Changes come whether or not everyone's research supports it...
https://carcaretotal.com/led-vs-hid/
Last edited by superdenso; 03-04-2018 at 11:41 PM.
#19
Join Date: May 2017
Location: Washington State
Posts: 14,809
Received 2,465 Likes
on
2,157 Posts
Coupe 6MT Premium RAS
That article was fairly slanted against HID and there was at least one glaring outright LIE about time for burn-in being 15-20 seconds...
That is a fair description of solid state MH or HPS lamps, yes they are HID but they're the ones used to light your streets and buildings and are NOT the same as instant strike Zenon lamps.
Again it all comes down to the assembly as a whole providing correctly focused light, wasted lumens is bad and retro kits are notorious for having poor visibility due to it.
They both have pro's and con's, the biggest selling point for LED is the longevity but something that's not even mentioned is how succeptible the encapsulation resin is to UV damage. A HID is a glass lamp and the only UV damaged component is the polycarbonate lense on the front of the assembly.
I doubt the auto industry will ever fully switch to LED. Something even better will come along.
That is a fair description of solid state MH or HPS lamps, yes they are HID but they're the ones used to light your streets and buildings and are NOT the same as instant strike Zenon lamps.
Again it all comes down to the assembly as a whole providing correctly focused light, wasted lumens is bad and retro kits are notorious for having poor visibility due to it.
They both have pro's and con's, the biggest selling point for LED is the longevity but something that's not even mentioned is how succeptible the encapsulation resin is to UV damage. A HID is a glass lamp and the only UV damaged component is the polycarbonate lense on the front of the assembly.
I doubt the auto industry will ever fully switch to LED. Something even better will come along.
#20
Super Moderator
iTrader: (3)
Originally Posted by cleric670@gmail
That article was fairly slanted against HID and there was at least one glaring outright LIE about time for burn-in being 15-20 seconds...
That is a fair description of solid state MH or HPS lamps, yes they are HID but they're the ones used to light your streets and buildings and are NOT the same as instant strike Zenon lamps.
Again it all comes down to the assembly as a whole providing correctly focused light, wasted lumens is bad and retro kits are notorious for having poor visibility due to it.
They both have pro's and con's, the biggest selling point for LED is the longevity but something that's not even mentioned is how succeptible the encapsulation resin is to UV damage. A HID is a glass lamp and the only UV damaged component is the polycarbonate lense on the front of the assembly.
I doubt the auto industry will ever fully switch to LED. Something even better will come along.
That is a fair description of solid state MH or HPS lamps, yes they are HID but they're the ones used to light your streets and buildings and are NOT the same as instant strike Zenon lamps.
Again it all comes down to the assembly as a whole providing correctly focused light, wasted lumens is bad and retro kits are notorious for having poor visibility due to it.
They both have pro's and con's, the biggest selling point for LED is the longevity but something that's not even mentioned is how succeptible the encapsulation resin is to UV damage. A HID is a glass lamp and the only UV damaged component is the polycarbonate lense on the front of the assembly.
I doubt the auto industry will ever fully switch to LED. Something even better will come along.
OP, look, LED is being tested out right now and it works pretty great in housings designed for the LED. Your drop in bulb can never have the output of the good LED projectors.
NHTSA Headlight Test of 2018 cars, check it out. It might surprise you.
Honda has had some major issues with LED failures on their cars in the market. LED needs good cooling at these wattages and I don't think whoever is building their units is using proper cooling.
All I'm telling you, and if you get nothing else out of this, is that drop in LED Bulbs are a waste of money. Retrofit an HID projector or leave your HID factory set up alone.
#21
Join Date: May 2017
Location: Washington State
Posts: 14,809
Received 2,465 Likes
on
2,157 Posts
Coupe 6MT Premium RAS
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
fireblade
G35 Coupe V35 2003 - 07
3
04-07-2006 04:56 PM