impressions on SBD grounding wires
#31
It seems as if people are contradicting each other... How can two people say it will do nothing to the car, when two other people say it helps the shift lag tremendously... The one thing i hate about my 06 AT is how long the lag shift is.. and im sure i am not alone in this.. so for 90% of the people who get these grounding kits to say it helps their shifting lag.. isnt that enough alone to show its a mod worth getting?
#32
I'll put in my two cents in as well. I bought the 10 piece grounding wire 2 years ago I think. Had them installed but it did nothing for me. It's still on my car and I wonder if I take them out now will I actually notice any difference (which I highly doubt).
Just a quick background. This is my first automatic and I came from owning only M/T cars for about 13 or 14 years before my G so I kinda know what "lagging" means. Lagging on the G's slushbox is similar to most of the automatic cars I've driven. Tried using manumatic but it lags just as bad. The only good thing about it is it holds the gear for you (assuming it doesn't downshift when your speed decreases). With that being said, I don't even use manumatic anymore because nothing, I repeat nothing can replace the conventional M/T (although those new DSG/SMG or whatever clutchless automatic/manuals) can shift faster, I just like having the extra pedal and I missed it by not having one on my G.
Ok, enough of my background. Not to offend anyone, but the people whom said the grounding gear improves/elminates/helps on lagging and all the other goodies...are you guys also M/T drivers? M/T, you shift, clutch out and it's instant power. Slushbox, you step on gas, then you wait till energizer bunny comes out before it shifts gear and then it surge out and pins you back. I am just afraid that some of the "grouding gear" drivers may not know how to drive stick so they "may" not know how it truely feels with NO LAG. Some may also based their wording from other people's words or butt dyno. I don't mean to offend anyone but it may be the case for "some".
Just a quick background. This is my first automatic and I came from owning only M/T cars for about 13 or 14 years before my G so I kinda know what "lagging" means. Lagging on the G's slushbox is similar to most of the automatic cars I've driven. Tried using manumatic but it lags just as bad. The only good thing about it is it holds the gear for you (assuming it doesn't downshift when your speed decreases). With that being said, I don't even use manumatic anymore because nothing, I repeat nothing can replace the conventional M/T (although those new DSG/SMG or whatever clutchless automatic/manuals) can shift faster, I just like having the extra pedal and I missed it by not having one on my G.
Ok, enough of my background. Not to offend anyone, but the people whom said the grounding gear improves/elminates/helps on lagging and all the other goodies...are you guys also M/T drivers? M/T, you shift, clutch out and it's instant power. Slushbox, you step on gas, then you wait till energizer bunny comes out before it shifts gear and then it surge out and pins you back. I am just afraid that some of the "grouding gear" drivers may not know how to drive stick so they "may" not know how it truely feels with NO LAG. Some may also based their wording from other people's words or butt dyno. I don't mean to offend anyone but it may be the case for "some".
#33
There seems to be too much heat and not enough light on this.
In my first life (I was an electrical engineer before I went to Med school) we were easily able to measure electromagnetic output decreases following proper or increased grounding. From my professional experience the grounding kit may only have the effect of reducing static electricity or electromagnetic waves that interfere with the sound system quality. The other improvements attributed to the kit may be the placebo effect, as stated earlier. The science behind the purported other improvements (better shifting, increased power, more stability in electrical system, etc.) is far too shakey to draw a conclusion.
Is it possible that the grounding kit may be the G's version of the Tornado fuel saver gas devices (and the hemi head on some engines) which millions bought... millions swore by... thousands of mechanics smilingly installed (b/c they too believed the marketing) because it made sense.... and in the end, after it was shown to be a useless add-on, millions continue to purchase?
In my first life (I was an electrical engineer before I went to Med school) we were easily able to measure electromagnetic output decreases following proper or increased grounding. From my professional experience the grounding kit may only have the effect of reducing static electricity or electromagnetic waves that interfere with the sound system quality. The other improvements attributed to the kit may be the placebo effect, as stated earlier. The science behind the purported other improvements (better shifting, increased power, more stability in electrical system, etc.) is far too shakey to draw a conclusion.
Is it possible that the grounding kit may be the G's version of the Tornado fuel saver gas devices (and the hemi head on some engines) which millions bought... millions swore by... thousands of mechanics smilingly installed (b/c they too believed the marketing) because it made sense.... and in the end, after it was shown to be a useless add-on, millions continue to purchase?
Last edited by Braintree; 12-26-2008 at 11:30 AM.
#34
WHAT!! The Tornado doesn't work!!!
j/k of course. I'm on the fence as well. I've never used one of these kits of course on a G, but i've added supplimental grounds on other vehicles i've owned and didn't notice a thing. That's why i was curuous as to why this is such a hyped up mod for G's. I also have an electrical background and from what I know, it shouldn't really do much if anything. Of course I've never installed a kit on a G so i don't know for sure what it does.
If it works, great. If it does't? Well it can't hurt. I'm just not a fan of the million wires criss-crossing my engine bay.
j/k of course. I'm on the fence as well. I've never used one of these kits of course on a G, but i've added supplimental grounds on other vehicles i've owned and didn't notice a thing. That's why i was curuous as to why this is such a hyped up mod for G's. I also have an electrical background and from what I know, it shouldn't really do much if anything. Of course I've never installed a kit on a G so i don't know for sure what it does.
If it works, great. If it does't? Well it can't hurt. I'm just not a fan of the million wires criss-crossing my engine bay.
#35
#36
WHAT!! The Tornado doesn't work!!!
j/k of course. I'm on the fence as well. I've never used one of these kits of course on a G, but i've added supplimental grounds on other vehicles i've owned and didn't notice a thing. That's why i was curuous as to why this is such a hyped up mod for G's. I also have an electrical background and from what I know, it shouldn't really do much if anything. Of course I've never installed a kit on a G so i don't know for sure what it does.
If it works, great. If it does't? Well it can't hurt. I'm just not a fan of the million wires criss-crossing my engine bay.
j/k of course. I'm on the fence as well. I've never used one of these kits of course on a G, but i've added supplimental grounds on other vehicles i've owned and didn't notice a thing. That's why i was curuous as to why this is such a hyped up mod for G's. I also have an electrical background and from what I know, it shouldn't really do much if anything. Of course I've never installed a kit on a G so i don't know for sure what it does.
If it works, great. If it does't? Well it can't hurt. I'm just not a fan of the million wires criss-crossing my engine bay.
Last edited by dmitriylm; 12-26-2008 at 01:08 PM.
#37
WHAT!! The Tornado doesn't work!!!
j/k of course. I'm on the fence as well. I've never used one of these kits of course on a G, but i've added supplimental grounds on other vehicles i've owned and didn't notice a thing. That's why i was curuous as to why this is such a hyped up mod for G's. I also have an electrical background and from what I know, it shouldn't really do much if anything. Of course I've never installed a kit on a G so i don't know for sure what it does.
If it works, great. If it does't? Well it can't hurt. I'm just not a fan of the million wires criss-crossing my engine bay.
j/k of course. I'm on the fence as well. I've never used one of these kits of course on a G, but i've added supplimental grounds on other vehicles i've owned and didn't notice a thing. That's why i was curuous as to why this is such a hyped up mod for G's. I also have an electrical background and from what I know, it shouldn't really do much if anything. Of course I've never installed a kit on a G so i don't know for sure what it does.
If it works, great. If it does't? Well it can't hurt. I'm just not a fan of the million wires criss-crossing my engine bay.
The point is if there are enough people that want to believe, it can become fact that the mod works even if there isn't isn't anything to support the claims. I've seen this in every forum I spend time on. Some claims are absolutely ridiculous and impossible. Over my years of modding, I've become pessimistic because I've bought into the claims a few too many times and wasted a lot of money. A lot of people aren't willing to post the negatives of a mod and will only point out the good things. This really ticks me off. If you're going to give a review, please be honest.
I'll get off my soap box now.
#38
True. When was the last time you saw a high end Japanese tuner or factory Japanese race car with grounding wires?
#39
the only two things i really noticed was the manumatic shift mode shifts with ~.5 sec delay vs ~1+ sec delay and the AT shifting is much smoother, could "almost" past as CVT....i also replaced my battery at the same time, so was it a placebo effect?
what about the hyper sun auto grounding kit? that has its' own module to regulate the voltage....
what about the hyper sun auto grounding kit? that has its' own module to regulate the voltage....
#40
#41
That's why I was scratching my head. I've been on the Domestic V8 side of things now for 10+ years. The most we ever did was add ONE supplimental engine ground from the engine block to the chassis as a backup. We never went as far as criss-crossing the engine bay like posted before.
I've been around some high dollor, high HP, EFI V8 engines and other than 1 single good engine ground, there was no supplimental grounding at all. I've never even heard of doing this until buying myself a G35 and coming here to learn all I can.
#42
I could careless if my sound is louder in the car.. i could get some subs if i wanted louder music.. all i care about is getting rid of that lag between shifts... is there any solid proof out there that grounding wires WILL decrease lag, and is there any solid proof that it WONT help the lag between shifts. Thats what im trying to get at.
#44
Joined: Sep 2008
Posts: 6,877
Likes: 59
From: Orange County
#45
I could careless if my sound is louder in the car.. i could get some subs if i wanted louder music.. all i care about is getting rid of that lag between shifts... is there any solid proof out there that grounding wires WILL decrease lag, and is there any solid proof that it WONT help the lag between shifts. Thats what im trying to get at.