Hi All: Even though I only have 16k on the OEM Goodyears GSA {there're just OK}, the ride quality has diminished. I beginning to research for the "best" replacements. Looking at Michelins, Yokohamas, BF Goodrich......What do you guys think ??

 

Assuming you are planning to continue with the OEM 17" wheels and are looking for all seasons there are choices. I thought of getting Yoko w. drive for better winter traction but now think that all seasons would be just fine for the NYC-LI-Westchester area where I drive 90% of the time.

I like the Michelin Pilot A/S but not the price. Bridgestone Turanza, Yokohama S4 and Goodyear Eagle GTs are other finee options, and I am also considering Kumho ecsta LX but am a bit wary of thier 101 load rating for 17" stock size affecting the ride adversely. So far, leaning towards Yokos but would also like to hear from others re. their stock X replacement all season choices.

 

I can vouch for the Kumho Ecsta LX...a friend just did the Kumhos on his '07 G35x (from the original RSAs)...The ride is excellent and quiet (esp compared to worn G'years)...It seems the "SUV-like" 101 load rating really has no ill effects and the snow traction is better than noted in some reviews...The 600 treadwear certainly seems optimistic for Z-rated donuts but time will tell (I have 18s on my 08 Sport - but I'm considering the LXs also to replace the Dunlop Sports - now made in 225/50R18 as well as the "standard" 225/55R17)...I've had good luck overall with Kumhos (Solus on our Pilot and ASXs - 235/40R18s - on my previous 06 A4)...Reasonably priced also...Definitely a better "value" than most...

 

I put 225/55 17 Goodyear Eagle GT's for winter. Love them so far and they look good too.