I've never driven a car with the Rogue.

I bought the Revo for 3 reasons. I've had experience with them as they make the best short shifters for Hondas, the Rogue equivalent that shortens shifts by 40% was hard to come by, and the Rogue required more parts and work to install where the Revo is a direct drop-in.

As for how well the Revo works, I lubed it up really well, and it worked fine, was as smooth as the stock shifter.