Rattel noise, smell, power loss
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 4,557
Likes: 106
From: Dallas, TX

Rattel noise, smell, power loss
All of a sudden since yesterday Im having some issues and Im guessing it has something to do with my Crawford HFCs???
1. Random rattling sound coming from under body passenger side. sound is not consistent.
2. Weird smell coming when Im sitting in the car and windows are down.
3. Loss of power (this one Im not 100% sure).
Any ideas what might be the issue?
Btw, its a 2006 g35 coupe 6mt
1. Random rattling sound coming from under body passenger side. sound is not consistent.
2. Weird smell coming when Im sitting in the car and windows are down.
3. Loss of power (this one Im not 100% sure).
Any ideas what might be the issue?
Btw, its a 2006 g35 coupe 6mt
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 4,557
Likes: 106
From: Dallas, TX

I found this...
https://g35driver.com/forums/3721998-post5.html
So, that might be the rattling issue... as the rattle is not at a certain rpm or anything.
When I crank up the car, if the rattle starts then, it stays. And its LOUD!
If the rattle doesnt start when I crank up the car, it never comes.
But what about the smell???
https://g35driver.com/forums/3721998-post5.html
So, that might be the rattling issue... as the rattle is not at a certain rpm or anything.
When I crank up the car, if the rattle starts then, it stays. And its LOUD!
If the rattle doesnt start when I crank up the car, it never comes.
But what about the smell???
Last edited by syshs; Mar 5, 2010 at 12:24 PM.
could very well be the comb inside the cells may have cracked and gone bad. Thats the only thing i can think of that have those 3 symptoms you described.
1. Rattling Sound - Cells have cracked and the core pieces are rattling around in the converter.
2. Smell - Cracked/broken core pieces are not filtering/absorbing the exhaust which is causing it to just run straight through, hence smelling that fuel and unconverted exhaust gases
3. Loss of power - Broken Cells/core pieces could be clogging the cats which is causing the loss of power.
I remember you bought those cats used and had quite a bit of miles on them. So they could just be bad and time to replace them.
1. Rattling Sound - Cells have cracked and the core pieces are rattling around in the converter.
2. Smell - Cracked/broken core pieces are not filtering/absorbing the exhaust which is causing it to just run straight through, hence smelling that fuel and unconverted exhaust gases
3. Loss of power - Broken Cells/core pieces could be clogging the cats which is causing the loss of power.
I remember you bought those cats used and had quite a bit of miles on them. So they could just be bad and time to replace them.
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 4,557
Likes: 106
From: Dallas, TX

^ Yes, I asked Jake, n thats what he guessed as well.
But, wouldn't the rattle be there every time I crank up the car?
Like I said...
But, wouldn't the rattle be there every time I crank up the car?
Like I said...
Could be the way the core pieces move around after driving your car around. Everytime you drive it it moves the broken pieces around and it settles differently, so sometimes loud rattles, sometimes no rattle...thats my best guess. 
I would definitely check the heat shields/O2 sensor, etc and make sure nothing is loose. If it isn't those, then most likely the cats.

I would definitely check the heat shields/O2 sensor, etc and make sure nothing is loose. If it isn't those, then most likely the cats.
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 4,557
Likes: 106
From: Dallas, TX

Yea nothings lose.
I took it to a muffler shop and had them bend the metal shields above the HFCs so that they dont touch the HFCs.
Havent been able to reproduce the sound since... if it returns, I will take the HFCs out and put the stockies back on.
I took it to a muffler shop and had them bend the metal shields above the HFCs so that they dont touch the HFCs.
Havent been able to reproduce the sound since... if it returns, I will take the HFCs out and put the stockies back on.
Trending Topics
I was about to say the exact same thing that Domenic said.. (great minds).. I hope all is well now Bro.. I know how much it sucks to have your car working, then all of a sudden when things are going well, something rains on your parade.
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 4,557
Likes: 106
From: Dallas, TX

^ haha ya, you said it!
just when everything is going groovy, something pops out of nowhere.
my gf sometimes doubts if she is the #1 girl in my life or my G.
just when everything is going groovy, something pops out of nowhere.
my gf sometimes doubts if she is the #1 girl in my life or my G.
I'm right there w/ ya bro.. Especially after this next batch of upgrades that I've done/am in the process of doing.. I'm not done YET.. HEHEHEHEHEHE!!!
You have a Girlfriend? Dang.. that's news to me.. (not saying you couldn't get one, I just always assumed you had a monogomous relationship w/ the G... PLAYA PLAYA!!!)
You have a Girlfriend? Dang.. that's news to me.. (not saying you couldn't get one, I just always assumed you had a monogomous relationship w/ the G... PLAYA PLAYA!!!)
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 4,557
Likes: 106
From: Dallas, TX

Haha! Over a year... its on my fb.
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 4,557
Likes: 106
From: Dallas, TX

so, took the HFCs out and my passenger side HFC is busted!
driver side pic... a-ok condition!

passenger side pic... busted!

hope the symptoms mentioned above help somebody diagnose the problem in the future.
driver side pic... a-ok condition!

passenger side pic... busted!

hope the symptoms mentioned above help somebody diagnose the problem in the future.
crawford hfc's! mine did that too! at least im guessing their crawfords
edit finally read the thread, but yea mine did the same thing...since i bought them from a member crawford couldnt do anything since i didnt have a receipt
edit finally read the thread, but yea mine did the same thing...since i bought them from a member crawford couldnt do anything since i didnt have a receipt
my passenger side did the same thing recently (20+K miles)...
I didnt notice which side your is op - but there is a used one (not broken) for sale in the marketplace... I would have bought it if I saw it before purchasing a new replacement.
eventually all hfc will go bad... most ppl say about 20K is the expected life... some get more, some get less...
I didnt notice which side your is op - but there is a used one (not broken) for sale in the marketplace... I would have bought it if I saw it before purchasing a new replacement.
eventually all hfc will go bad... most ppl say about 20K is the expected life... some get more, some get less...
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
magnetism80
G35 Coupe V35 2003 - 07
5
Feb 1, 2019 10:00 AM
Rhinos7777
Engine, Drivetrain & Forced-Induction
3
Sep 6, 2015 05:36 PM





