3rd party independant tear down results of a failed VQ motor.

Subscribe
Oct 26, 2008 | 02:28 PM
  #151  
Quote: i know, so its hard to understand how come Arias produce a bad gtm spec piston all fo the sudden
Evidentally there was a problems a couple of years ago. Perhaps they were old inventory that Arias sent to GTM used by mistake, or that GTM missed when purging their old inventory.
Oct 26, 2008 | 03:24 PM
  #152  
Quote: Too say Sam is selling you bad batches of engines are not fixing it or taking care of it isn't him, few people that know him too well, know well enough he will not ever do anything scandalous like that. I don't know why you sent your motor out to a 3rd party either hrrrm....what i think, you plan this shiet all out man from the begining, these motors aren't from like yesterday, its been a batch of motors from a while back, and I think if it was bad it would of went bad during day 1 or during your tune on the spot. I don't know though, but this is my opinion, I think you my friend, are busting a shady. And no I'm not backing up Sam up on this issue because I'm a customer there, what do i know of this situation truly? This is my opinion although I tend to support him as a customer and a friend. Unless there was really a failed part on gtm's side, Julian you have something up your sleeve, you fvcked up and trying to get something out of it and blame the finger somewhere else, i know it Julian, you know it Julian, you know it man......its ok though. Btw where da fvck is mrc? hahaha
Wait, Wat? I have no clue what your attempting to say.
Oct 26, 2008 | 03:53 PM
  #153  
Wow...people now started taking side eventhough they don't even know what and how the truth was.

Why not just let MRC and GTM solve this by themselves? All we need to do is just sit back and watch, the truth would be out soon.

This thread is getting alonger because of those useless posts.
Oct 26, 2008 | 03:57 PM
  #154  
Here are a few more pictures of the motor we had blueprinted.Note in the last picutre the gouges in the main bearing that was done upon assembly at GTM, you can clearly see it is BELOW the visible wear mark, showing that is was there from the start.Note the Oil gunk burnt to the inside of the cylinder walls as well as the valves keeping them from properly seating. This was due to the sloppy and 30 thousanths of oil ring end gap and improper piston to wall. This motor was doomed from day one. With overtight mains and loose ring gap.








3rd party independant tear down results of a failed VQ motor.-5.jpg  

Oct 26, 2008 | 04:03 PM
  #155  
Don't post much but I think this is something to comment on. I am in the FI forum everyday about 10 times a day and read a lot. From this experience, I don't think anyone should say that they have to rethink going to GTM or rethink going to MRC. I live in NY and out of all places, if I decide to move forward with my project it will be MRC just because they are 45 minutes from my house. Additionally, Julian would have to build my motor, do the install, and tune the car. And the main reason is that if anything were to fail, I can go back to Julian. When you ask every question from who built the engine, to who tuned the car, to who changed the oil....the answer will be the same for every question. Once there is only one person to point the finger at, there can be no finger pointing. If I lived in CA, it would be the same scenerio but it would be with GTM. Its always easier for a shop to resolve a matter if they know that there was not another shop involved with the tune or install of their product. We have said this time and time again and this is just another situation that brings it this into a brighter light that its better to have everything from one shop. Good luck to both parties and the customer.
Oct 26, 2008 | 04:07 PM
  #156  
Shop nuthuggers and personal rivals (KP) getting involved in this thread FTL.
Oct 26, 2008 | 04:10 PM
  #157  
Quote: Don't post much but I think this is something to comment on. I am in the FI forum everyday about 10 times a day and read a lot. From this experience, I don't think anyone should say that they have to rethink going to GTM or rethink going to MRC. I live in NY and out of all places, if I decide to move forward with my project it will be MRC just because they are 45 minutes from my house. Additionally, Julian would have to build my motor, do the install, and tune the car. And the main reason is that if anything were to fail, I can go back to Julian. When you ask every question from who built the engine, to who tuned the car, to who changed the oil....the answer will be the same for every question. Once there is only one person to point the finger at, there can be no finger pointing. If I lived in CA, it would be the same scenerio but it would be with GTM. Its always easier for a shop to resolve a matter if they know that there was not another shop involved with the tune or install of their product. We have said this time and time again and this is just another situation that brings it this into a brighter light that its better to have everything from one shop. Good luck to both parties and the customer.
Well said.
Oct 26, 2008 | 04:18 PM
  #158  
Quote: Shop nuthuggers and personal rivals (KP) getting involved in this thread FTL.
It doesnt Phase me, I can hang with the best of em...No pun intended. However it is hard to dispute cold hard FACTS and pictures backing up the FACTS. When there is no disputing things such this, the inevitable bashing then take place in an attempt to distract and discredit the person calling the BS.
This was the same situation when we all cried BS on VRT back 3 years ago....The truth eventually came out.
Oct 26, 2008 | 04:33 PM
  #159  
I have the actual inspection report if anyone cares to view i need someone to host it, its 393 KB....i honestly do not know how much more factual information we have to provide to get Sam to admit he F'd up. also we got back a preliminary on Romes new motor, and despite Sams suggestion that we mistimed the cams, the engine and cam timing was 100% correct. Ball is in Sams court now, since all we did to that motor was time it and put the cover on...FYI that motor was NOT tuned, only started up.
Oct 26, 2008 | 04:58 PM
  #160  
Quote: Shop nuthuggers and personal rivals (KP) getting involved in this thread FTL.
I brought up valid questions and points and did not disrespect either shop (as there isn't enough info available to make a conclusive judgement over the internet). If you percieved my post as hostile towards Julian because Julian and I had issues 6 months ago then thats on you - that wasn't my intention at all. There is no "rivalry" between Julian and me - what's in the past is in the past.

There are questions that need to be answered, and one of them is what kind of warranty does GTM offer on motors they sell to other vendors? There are obviously all kinds of different costs involved (labor, shipping, trouble shooting, etc) and someone needs to be responsible for them so when situations like this arise there is a clear understanding of who will do what. Two shops pointing fingers at each other is bad for the community and bad for the customer. Sadly this isn't the first thread about someone having issues with a motor built one place and installed/tuned somewhere else. Hopefully people that are going to have motors built in the future learn from this situation and ask questions about warranties before they spend their hard earned money.

I do hope that whatever the findings MRC and GTM find a way to work together to get the car in question back on the road in a timely manner.
Oct 26, 2008 | 04:59 PM
  #161  
Quote: I have the actual inspection report if anyone cares to view i need someone to host it, its 393 KB....i honestly do not know how much more factual information we have to provide to get Sam to admit he F'd up. also we got back a preliminary on Romes new motor, and despite Sams suggestion that we mistimed the cams, the engine and cam timing was 100% correct. Ball is in Sams court now, since all we did to that motor was time it and put the cover on...FYI that motor was NOT tuned, only started up.
I can host it if you want me to.
Oct 26, 2008 | 05:03 PM
  #162  
Mabe GTM builds terrible motors, and MRC sucks at tunning them.

Just wanted to call out both shops, to keep this pointless drama going.
Oct 26, 2008 | 05:19 PM
  #163  
^awesome post bra
Oct 26, 2008 | 05:45 PM
  #164  
Julian, the fact that you've made enemies on the internet is a sign. GTM, as far as I know, does not have any series issues with any vendors on the site(s).

Lets not dig up any buried skeletons now, and focus on the issue at hand, which is regarding the motors in question.

I'm sure both sides are leaving out important pieces of evidence, and IMO, this shouldn't have even come up until it was settled. Going public with it is just your way of pushing for something to happen faster instead of going through the proper channels.

Is Julian going to be the next Relentless?

I'm going to step out of this thread for now and just watch it develop.
Oct 26, 2008 | 05:46 PM
  #165  
Honestly, some of you are wasting your breathes with pointless bias opinions or maybe you're just ignorant of the facts. As many has stated before me, this is a legal matter and let the lawyers finish it. Some of you still don't understand we are involve in something called... "THE INTERNET" ?

This is like a basketball game... we won't know who wins till the end. I'm rooting for GTM, so lets sit back and enjoy the game!

I want more updated legal news and less pointless bias opinions.

Thank you